Castillo-Allendes Adrián, Cantor-Cutiva Lady Catherine, Vidal Verónica, Hunter Eric J
Department of Communicative Sciences and Disorders, Michigan State University, East Lansing, Michigan; Department of Communication Sciences and Disorders, University of Iowa, Iowa City, Iowa.
Department of Communication Sciences and Disorders, University of Iowa, Iowa City, Iowa.
J Voice. 2024 Oct 9. doi: 10.1016/j.jvoice.2024.09.021.
Teachers rely heavily on their voices, making them susceptible to voice disorders affecting their teaching efficacy and well-being. This study explores the role of voice as a working tool for teachers and its impact on their professional lives, a necessary step in designing intervention points.
Using a phenomenological approach, we conducted qualitative interviews with 18 teachers (13 females, 5 males) from diverse backgrounds. They represented diverse teaching areas, grade levels, and school districts. Data were analyzed through content analysis. In this process, 52 codes were identified, totaling 753 code references.
This study uncovered insights into the role of voice as a working tool for teachers and its impact on their professional lives. In-depth analysis of the interviews with 18 teachers resulted in 6 key themes: (1) Voice is a crucial occupational tool for teachers for instruction, engagement, and classroom management; (2) working conditions significantly impact teachers' vocal health, with environmental factors and vocal load contributing to voice problems; (3) vocal health concerns are frequently reported by teachers, emphasizing the need for comprehensive health management strategies; (4) there are notable best practices and gaps in vocal care, with teachers expressing the need for more resources and formal training; (5) amplification devices play a significant role in sustaining teachers' vocal health, although access to and use of these tools is inconsistent; and (6) voice-related problems have a significant emotional and psychosocial impact on teachers, affecting their self-perception, professional identity, and well-being.
This study highlights the critical role of vocal health in teachers' professional lives, revealing its impact on teaching efficacy, well-being, and professional identity. The findings highlight the need for comprehensive support systems, including vocal health programs, resources like amplification devices, and counseling for emotional impacts. The six identified themes emphasize the necessity of holistic interventions to enhance teachers' well-being and effectiveness.
教师严重依赖嗓音,这使他们容易患上嗓音疾病,进而影响教学效果和身心健康。本研究探讨嗓音作为教师工作工具的作用及其对教师职业生活的影响,这是设计干预点的必要步骤。
采用现象学方法,我们对18名来自不同背景的教师(13名女性,5名男性)进行了定性访谈。他们代表了不同的教学领域、年级水平和学区。通过内容分析对数据进行了分析。在此过程中,识别出52个编码,共计753个编码引用。
本研究揭示了嗓音作为教师工作工具的作用及其对教师职业生活的影响。对18名教师的访谈进行深入分析后得出6个关键主题:(1)嗓音是教师进行教学、吸引学生参与和课堂管理的关键职业工具;(2)工作条件对教师的嗓音健康有显著影响,环境因素和嗓音负荷会导致嗓音问题;(3)教师经常报告嗓音健康问题,强调需要全面的健康管理策略;(4)在嗓音护理方面存在显著的最佳实践和差距,教师表示需要更多资源和正规培训;(5)扩音设备在维持教师嗓音健康方面发挥着重要作用,尽管这些工具的获取和使用并不一致;(6)与嗓音相关的问题对教师有重大的情感和心理社会影响,影响他们的自我认知、职业认同和幸福感。
本研究强调了嗓音健康在教师职业生活中的关键作用,揭示了其对教学效果、幸福感和职业认同的影响。研究结果强调需要全面的支持系统,包括嗓音健康计划、扩音设备等资源以及针对情感影响的咨询服务。确定的六个主题强调了进行整体干预以提高教师幸福感和效能的必要性。