Gebhard Amanda, Allen Willow Samara, Pino Fritz
Faculty of Social Work, University of Regina, Canada.
Department of Adult EducationFaculty of Education, St. Francis Xavier University, Canada.
Action Res (Lond). 2024 Dec;22(4):345-361. doi: 10.1177/14767503231210418. Epub 2023 Nov 3.
Appreciative inquiry is an action research methodology focused on revealing an organization's positive core. As a cross-racial team of antiracist researchers, we were drawn to appreciative inquiry due to its congruences with community-based research perspectives on power-sharing and co-constructing knowledge. Our collaborative reflexivity brought us to question whether Appreciative inquiry's hyper-focus on positivity would fit our antiracist research paradigm. We articulate reflections of how antiracism theory informed our approach to Appreciative inquiry in a study on the experiences of predominantly racialized settlement workers in schools during the COVID-19 pandemic. We explain how we negotiated tensions between Appreciative inquiry's focus on positivity and our antiracist framing, in a Canadian settler colonial context where institutional expectations to ignore racism and collapse diversity, loom large. Without a theoretical framework that attends to racism and power, Appreciative inquiry may not fulsomely address participants' transnational knowledges, nor experiences outside of a positive/negative binary. In our elucidation of how critical reflexivity on racism allowed us to integrate antiracism into Appreciative inquiry, we demonstrate the value of first-person action research for expanding the social justice aims of research.
欣赏式探询是一种行动研究方法,专注于揭示组织的积极核心。作为一个跨种族的反种族主义研究团队,我们被欣赏式探询所吸引,因为它与基于社区的研究中关于权力分享和共同构建知识的观点相一致。我们的协作反思促使我们质疑欣赏式探询对积极性的过度关注是否符合我们的反种族主义研究范式。在一项关于新冠疫情期间学校中主要为种族化移民工人经历的研究中,我们阐述了反种族主义理论如何为我们运用欣赏式探询的方法提供指导。我们解释了在加拿大定居者殖民背景下,当机构期望忽视种族主义并消解多样性的情况十分突出时,我们是如何协调欣赏式探询对积极性的关注与我们的反种族主义框架之间的矛盾的。如果没有一个关注种族主义和权力的理论框架,欣赏式探询可能无法充分处理参与者的跨国知识,也无法处理积极/消极二元之外的经历。在我们阐明对种族主义的批判性反思如何使我们将反种族主义融入欣赏式探询的过程中我们展示了第一人称行动研究对于拓展研究的社会正义目标的价值。