Casamassimo Paul S
Division of Pediatric Dentistry, College of Dentistry, The Ohio State University, Columbus, OH 43214, USA.
Nationwide Children's Hospital, Columbus, OH 43205, USA.
Healthcare (Basel). 2024 Sep 27;12(19):1935. doi: 10.3390/healthcare12191935.
Behavior management as a set of clinical techniques to induce desirable clinical treatment and subsequent compliance behaviors in children and families varies internationally based on professional training, access to care, health literacy, and societal norms. This report proposes non-typical diagnostic considerations of additional inherent behavioral conditions and familial and social qualifiers that may help predict success both at the chairside and in compliance with home self-care behaviors to reduce caries susceptibility.
A review of the medical and dental literature provides ample support for the consideration of changing characteristics of both the patient and the environment.
The current recommendations for choice of behavior guidance in direct clinical care, as used in the USA, often fall short of efficacy for a variety of reasons including the provider limitations, the extent and difficulty of treatment, and most recently appreciated, the complexity of negative childhood experiences, subclinical behavioral disorders, and immutable negative determinants of health outside the dental setting affecting interaction with health professionals. These same factors, such as family dysfunction and societal stresses, also impact compliance with out-of-clinic preventive efforts that many oral health care providers rely upon to help mitigate treatment limitations in reaching children. There are also behavioral elements of compliance and attitudes toward health that dentists need to recognize.
A broader, more inclusive concept of behavior guidance to include factors beyond those typically associated with a dental patient affecting treatment and compliance with preventive behaviors may be beneficial. Every population and patient will have differing characteristics and require individualized care.
行为管理作为一套旨在促使儿童及其家庭产生理想临床治疗及后续依从行为的临床技术,在国际上因专业培训、医疗服务可及性、健康素养和社会规范的不同而存在差异。本报告提出对额外内在行为状况以及家庭和社会限定因素的非典型诊断考量,这些因素可能有助于预测在诊疗过程中以及家庭自我护理行为依从性方面的成功,从而降低龋齿易感性。
对医学和牙科文献的回顾为考虑患者和环境的变化特征提供了充分支持。
在美国直接临床护理中当前使用的行为指导选择建议,由于多种原因往往效果不佳,这些原因包括提供者的局限性、治疗的范围和难度,以及最近认识到的童年负面经历的复杂性、亚临床行为障碍,以及牙科环境之外影响与医疗专业人员互动的健康不可改变的负面决定因素。这些相同的因素,如家庭功能失调和社会压力,也会影响许多口腔保健提供者所依赖的门诊外预防措施的依从性,这些措施有助于减轻在为儿童提供治疗方面的局限性。牙医还需要认识到依从性的行为要素以及对健康的态度。
更广泛、更具包容性的行为指导概念,将通常与牙科患者相关的影响治疗和预防行为依从性的因素之外的其他因素纳入其中,可能会有所助益。每个群体和患者都有不同的特征,需要个性化护理。