Stolz Regina, Klocke Carina, Mahler Cornelia, Valentini Jan, Joos Stefanie
Institute of General Practice and Interprofessional Care, University Hospital and Faculty of Medicine, Tübingen, Germany.
Department of Nursing Science, Institute for Health Sciences, University Hospital and Faculty of Medicine, Tübingen, Germany.
Front Med (Lausanne). 2024 Oct 3;11:1438035. doi: 10.3389/fmed.2024.1438035. eCollection 2024.
Integrative nursing interventions (INI) play a significant role in healthcare, particularly in the prevention and treatment of chronic diseases. Integrating evidence-based INI into healthcare aligns with global initiatives such as the WHO's Decade of Healthy Aging 2020-2030. Many INI are low-threshold practices, empowering patients to independently manage health. However, the extent to which INI are used by home-care nursing-services (HNS) remains largely unknown. This study aims to explore the field of INI in German HNS regarding nurses' use of INI as well as attitudes, subjective knowledge, and information needs on the subject.
A cross-sectional anonymous online survey with 29 Likert scale items and two open-ended questions was conducted between April 2023 and July 2023. The survey targeted nurse managers of HNS in Baden-Württemberg, Germany. Descriptive analysis was performed for quantitative data, while content analysis according to Kuckartz was applied to analyze open-ended text responses.
In total, = 68 out of = 1,331 HNS took part in the survey yielding a response rate of 5.1%. Their overall attitude toward INI was clearly positive (10-point Likert scale M ± SD: 8.37 ± 2.22). The average self-assessed knowledge level about INI was moderate (M ± SD: 5.39 ± 2.76). Almost half of the participants (45.6%) declared to incorporate INI in patient care. Most participants (84.2%) lacked employees with additional qualifications in INI. The INI used most were medicinal herbal teas (61%), compresses (57%), and aromatherapy (48%). Acupressure showed the greatest disparity between actual use in participating HNS (4.3%) and interest in further education (61%). The most common symptoms for which INI are used are pain, respiratory problems, anxiety, and palliative care. The main challenges reported for the use of INI in HNS are financial aspects, qualification and limited resources (staff and time).
This exploratory study provides the first insights into nurses' attitudes, self-assessed knowledge, and utilization of INI in German HNS. Overall response rate was low (5.1%), therefore, the results should be interpreted with caution. Urgent action is needed to address financial aspects and further education on INI, to promote integration of INI in HNS to the best possible extent.
综合护理干预措施(INI)在医疗保健中发挥着重要作用,尤其是在慢性病的预防和治疗方面。将基于证据的INI纳入医疗保健与诸如世界卫生组织2020 - 2030年健康老龄化十年等全球倡议相一致。许多INI都是低门槛的做法,使患者能够独立管理健康。然而,家庭护理服务(HNS)对INI的使用程度在很大程度上仍然未知。本研究旨在探讨德国HNS中INI领域关于护士对INI的使用情况以及对该主题的态度、主观知识和信息需求。
在2023年4月至2023年7月期间进行了一项横断面匿名在线调查,该调查有29个李克特量表项目和两个开放式问题。调查对象是德国巴登 - 符腾堡州HNS的护士长。对定量数据进行描述性分析,同时根据库卡茨方法进行内容分析以分析开放式文本回复。
在1331个HNS中,共有68个参与了调查(回复率为百分之5.1)。他们对INI的总体态度明显积极(10分李克特量表,M ± SD:8.37 ± 2.22)。对INI的自我评估知识水平平均为中等(M ± SD:5.39 ± 2.76)。几乎一半的参与者(45.6%)宣称在患者护理中纳入了INI。大多数参与者(84.2%)缺乏具备INI额外资质的员工。使用最多的INI是药草茶(61%)、热敷(57%)和芳香疗法(48%)。在参与调查的HNS中,指压疗法的实际使用(4.3%)与继续教育兴趣(61%)之间差异最大。使用INI最常见的症状是疼痛、呼吸问题、焦虑和姑息治疗。HNS中使用INI报告的主要挑战是财务方面、资质以及资源有限(人员和时间)。
这项探索性研究首次深入了解了德国HNS中护士对INI的态度、自我评估知识以及使用情况。总体回复率较低(5.1%),因此,对结果的解释应谨慎。需要采取紧急行动来解决INI的财务方面和继续教育问题,以尽可能促进INI在HNS中的整合。