McWilliams Center for Cosmology, Department of Physics, Carnegie Mellon University, Pittsburgh, PA, USA.
Nature. 2024 Oct;634(8036):1065-1069. doi: 10.1038/s41586-024-08065-w. Epub 2024 Oct 23.
Fast radio bursts (FRBs) are a newly discovered class of extragalactic radio transients characterized by their high energy and short duration (from microseconds to milliseconds). The physical origin of these FRBs remains unknown and is a subject of ongoing research, with magnetars emerging as leading candidates. Previous studies have used various methodologies to address the problem of FRB origin, including demographic analyses of FRB host galaxies and their local environments, assessments of FRB rate evolution with redshift and searches for proposed multi-messenger FRB counterparts. However, these studies are susceptible to substantial biases stemming from unaccounted radio and optical selection effects. Here we present empirical evidence for a substantial selection bias against detecting FRBs in galaxies with large inclination angles (edge-on) using a sample of hosts identified for FRBs discovered by untargeted surveys. This inclination-related bias probably leads to a significant underestimation (by about a factor of two) of the FRB rates reported in the literature and disfavours globular clusters as the dominant origin of FRB sources, as previously speculated. These conclusions have important implications for FRB progenitor models and targeted FRB follow-up strategies. We further investigate the impact of this bias on the relative rate of FRBs in different host environments. Our analysis suggests that scattering in FRB hosts is probably responsible for the observed bias. However, a larger sample of localized FRBs is required to robustly quantify the contribution of scattering to the inclination-related selection bias.
快速射电暴(FRBs)是一类新发现的河外射电暂现源,其特征为能量高、持续时间短(从微秒到毫秒)。这些 FRBs 的物理起源仍然未知,是正在进行的研究课题,磁星是最主要的候选者。先前的研究已经使用了各种方法来解决 FRB 起源问题,包括 FRB 宿主星系及其局部环境的人口统计学分析、FRB 率随红移的演化评估以及对多信使 FRB 对应体的搜索。然而,这些研究容易受到未考虑的无线电和光学选择效应的显著偏差的影响。在这里,我们使用未针对目标的调查发现的 FRB 宿主的样本,提供了关于在大倾斜角(侧对)星系中检测 FRB 存在实质性选择偏差的经验证据。这种与倾斜度相关的偏差可能导致对文献中报告的 FRB 率的显著低估(约为因子 2),并对以前推测的 FRB 源的主导起源——球状星团不利。这些结论对 FRB 先驱模型和有针对性的 FRB 后续策略具有重要意义。我们进一步研究了这种偏差对不同宿主环境中 FRB 相对率的影响。我们的分析表明,FRB 宿主中的散射可能是导致这种偏差的原因。然而,需要更大的局部 FRB 样本才能可靠地量化散射对与倾斜度相关的选择偏差的贡献。