Lieberman A, Neophytides A, Kupersmith M, Casson I, Durso R, Foo S H, Khayali M, Tartaro T, Goldstein M
Am J Med Sci. 1979 Jul-Aug;278(1):65-76. doi: 10.1097/00000441-197907000-00008.
Bromocriptine and lergotrile were administered to 81 patients with Parkinson disease (PD) and increasing disability despite optimal treatment with levodopa (secondary levodopa failures). Sixty-six patients were treated with bromocriptine and 53 patients were treated with lergotrile. Both groups had significantly decreased rigidity, tremor, bradykinesia and gait disturbance upon addition of bromocriptine or lergotrile to levodopa. Twenty-five patients improved at least one-stage on bromocriptine, and 21 improved at least one-stage on lergotrile. The mean dose of bromocriptine was 47 mg, and the mean dose of lergotrile was 49 mg, permitting a 10% reduction in levodopa. Bromocriptine was discontinued in 29 of 66 patients because of adverse effects, including mental changes (14 patients) and involuntary movements (9 patients). Lergotrile was discontinued in 33 of 53 patients because of adverse effects including hepatotoxicity (11 patients) and mental changes (12 patients). The results of treatment with bromocriptine or lergotrile were comparable, with patients either responding or not. Bromocriptine will shortly be available for use in PD. Lergotrile, because of the hepatotoxicity, will not.
对81例帕金森病(PD)患者进行了溴隐亭和麦角腈治疗,这些患者尽管接受了左旋多巴的最佳治疗(左旋多巴继发性失效),病情仍不断恶化。66例患者接受了溴隐亭治疗,53例患者接受了麦角腈治疗。在左旋多巴基础上加用溴隐亭或麦角腈后,两组患者的强直、震颤、运动迟缓及步态障碍均显著减轻。25例患者使用溴隐亭后病情至少改善一级,21例患者使用麦角腈后病情至少改善一级。溴隐亭的平均剂量为47mg,麦角腈的平均剂量为49mg,可使左旋多巴的用量减少10%。66例患者中有29例因不良反应停用溴隐亭,不良反应包括精神改变(14例)和不自主运动(9例)。53例患者中有33例因不良反应停用麦角腈,不良反应包括肝毒性(11例)和精神改变(12例)。溴隐亭和麦角腈的治疗结果相当,患者要么有反应,要么无反应。溴隐亭不久将可用于帕金森病治疗。而麦角腈因有肝毒性,将不会用于治疗。