Ali Amira Mohammed, Al-Dossary Saeed A, Laranjeira Carlos, Atout Maha, Khatatbeh Haitham, Selim Abeer, Alkhamees Abdulmajeed A, Aljaberi Musheer A, Pakai Annamária, Al-Dwaikat Tariq
Department of Psychiatric Nursing and Mental Health, Faculty of Nursing, Alexandria University, Smouha, Alexandria 21527, Egypt.
Department of Psychology, College of Education, University of Ha'il, Ha'il 1818, Saudi Arabia.
J Clin Med. 2024 Oct 10;13(20):6045. doi: 10.3390/jcm13206045.
Posttraumatic stress disorder (PTSD) and/or specific PTSD symptoms may evoke maladaptive behaviors (e.g., compulsive buying, disordered eating, and an unhealthy lifestyle), resulting in adverse cardiometabolic events (e.g., hypertension and obesity), which may implicate the treatment of this complex condition. The diagnostic criteria for PTSD have lately expanded beyond the three common symptoms (intrusion, avoidance, and hyperarousal). Including additional symptoms such as emotional numbing, sleep disturbance, and irritability strengthens the representation of the Impact of Event Scale-Revised (IES-R), suggesting that models with four, five, or six dimensions better capture its structure compared to the original three-dimensional model. Using a convenience sample of 58 Russian dental healthcare workers (HCWs: mean age = 44.1 ± 12.2 years, 82.8% females), this instrumental study examined the convergent, concurrent, and criterion validity of two IES-R structures: IES-R3 and IES-R6. Exploratory factor analysis uncovered five factors, which explained 76.0% of the variance in the IES-R. Subscales of the IES-R3 and the IES-R6 expressed good internal consistency (coefficient alpha range = 0.69-0.88), high convergent validity (item total correlations r range = 0.39-0.81, and correlations with the IES-R's total score r range = 0.62-0.92), excellent concurrent validity through strong correlations with the PTSD Symptom Scale-Self Report (PSS-SR: r range = 0.42-0.69), while their criterion validity was indicated by moderate-to-low correlations with high body mass index (BMI: r range = 0.12-0.39) and the diagnosis of hypertension (r range = 0.12-0.30). In the receiver-operating characteristic (ROC) curve analysis, all IES-R models were perfectly associated with the PSS-SR (all areas under the curve (AUCs) > 0.9, values < 0.001). The IES-R, both hyperarousal subscales, and the IES-R3 intrusion subscale were significantly associated with high BMI. Both avoidance subscales and the IES-R3 intrusion subscale, not the IES-R, were significantly associated with hypertension. In the two-step cluster analysis, five sets of all trauma variables (IES-R3/IES-R6, PSS-SR) classified the participants into two clusters according to their BMI (normal weight/low BMI vs. overweight/obese). Meanwhile, only the IES-R, PSS-SR, and IES-R3 dimensions successfully classified participants as having either normal blood pressure or hypertension. Participants in the overweight/obese and hypertensive clusters displayed considerably higher levels of most trauma symptoms. Input variables with the highest predictor importance in the cluster analysis were those variables expressing significant associations in correlations and ROC analyses. However, neither IES-R3 nor IES-R6 contributed to BMI or hypertension either directly or indirectly in the path analysis. Meanwhile, age significantly predicted both health conditions and current smoking. Irritability and numbing were the only IES-R dimensions that significantly contributed to current smoking. The findings emphasize the need for assessing the way through which various PTSD symptoms may implicate cardiometabolic dysfunctions and their risk factors (e.g., smoking and the intake of unhealthy foods) as well as the application of targeted dietary and exercise interventions to lower physical morbidity in PTSD patients. However, the internal and external validity of our tests may be questionable due to the low power of our sample size. Replicating the study in larger samples, which comprise different physical and mental conditions from heterogenous cultural contexts, is pivotal to validate the results (e.g., in specific groups, such as those with confirmed traumatic exposure and comorbid mood dysfunction).
创伤后应激障碍(PTSD)和/或特定的PTSD症状可能引发适应不良行为(如强迫性购物、饮食失调和不健康的生活方式),导致不良的心脏代谢事件(如高血压和肥胖),这可能涉及对这种复杂病症的治疗。PTSD的诊断标准最近已扩展到超出三个常见症状(侵入性、回避和过度警觉)。纳入诸如情感麻木、睡眠障碍和易怒等额外症状,增强了事件影响量表修订版(IES-R)的代表性,这表明与原始的三维模型相比,具有四个、五个或六个维度的模型能更好地捕捉其结构。本工具性研究使用了58名俄罗斯牙科医护人员的便利样本(医护人员:平均年龄 = 44.1 ± 12.2岁,82.8%为女性),检验了两种IES-R结构(IES-R3和IES-R6)的收敛效度、同时效度和标准效度。探索性因素分析揭示了五个因素,它们解释了IES-R中76.0%的方差。IES-R3和IES-R6的子量表表现出良好的内部一致性(系数阿尔法范围 = 0.69 - 0.88)、高收敛效度(项目总分相关性r范围 = 0.39 - 0.81,与IES-R总分的相关性r范围 = 0.62 - 0.92),通过与PTSD症状量表 - 自我报告(PSS-SR:r范围 = 0.42 - 0.69)的强相关性具有出色的同时效度,而它们的标准效度通过与高体重指数(BMI:r范围 = 0.12 - 0.39)和高血压诊断的中度至低度相关性来表明(r范围 = 0.12 - 0.30)。在接受者操作特征(ROC)曲线分析中,所有IES-R模型与PSS-SR完全相关(所有曲线下面积(AUCs)> 0.9,p值 < 0.001)。IES-R、两个过度警觉子量表以及IES-R3侵入性子量表与高BMI显著相关。两个回避子量表和IES-R3侵入性子量表(而非IES-R)与高血压显著相关。在两步聚类分析中,五组所有创伤变量(IES-R3/IES-R6、PSS-SR)根据参与者的BMI(正常体重/低BMI与超重/肥胖)将他们分为两个聚类。同时,只有IES-R、PSS-SR和IES-R3维度成功地将参与者分类为患有正常血压或高血压。超重/肥胖和高血压聚类中的参与者表现出大多数创伤症状的水平显著更高。聚类分析中预测重要性最高的输入变量是那些在相关性和ROC分析中表现出显著关联的变量。然而,在路径分析中,IES-R3和IES-R6均未直接或间接对BMI或高血压产生影响。同时,年龄显著预测了这两种健康状况和当前吸烟情况。易怒和麻木是仅有的对当前吸烟有显著贡献的IES-R维度。研究结果强调需要评估各种PTSD症状可能涉及心脏代谢功能障碍及其风险因素(如吸烟和不健康食物摄入)的方式,以及应用有针对性的饮食和运动干预措施来降低PTSD患者的身体发病率。然而,由于我们样本量的低效能,我们测试的内部和外部效度可能存在疑问。在更大的样本中重复该研究,这些样本包含来自不同文化背景的不同身体和心理状况,对于验证结果至关重要(例如在特定群体中,如那些有确诊创伤暴露和共病情绪功能障碍的群体)。