Zeidan Aya Mutaz, Xu Zhouyang, Leung Lisa, Byrne Calum, Sabu Sachin, Zhou Yijia, Rinaldi Christopher Aldo, Whitaker John, Williams Steven E, Behar Jonathan, Arujuna Aruna, Housden R James, Rhode Kawal
Department of Surgical & Interventional Engineering, King's College London, London, SE1 7EH, UK.
Cardiology Department, Guy's & St Thomas' NHS Foundation Trust, London, SE1 7EH, UK.
3D Print Med. 2024 Oct 30;10(1):34. doi: 10.1186/s41205-024-00241-y.
Transseptal puncture (TSP) is a critical prerequisite for left-sided cardiac interventions, such as atrial fibrillation (AF) ablation and left atrial appendage closure. Despite its routine nature, TSP can be technically demanding and carries a risk of complications. This study presents a novel, patient-specific, anthropomorphic phantom for TSP simulation training that can be used with X-ray fluoroscopy and ultrasound imaging.
The TSP phantom was developed using additive manufacturing techniques and features a replaceable fossa ovalis (FO) component to allow for multiple punctures without replacing the entire model. Four cardiologists and one cardiology trainee performed TSP on the simulator, and their performance was assessed using four metrics: global isotropy index, distance from the centroid, time taken to perform TSP, and a set of 5-point Likert scale questions to evaluate the clinicians' perception of the phantom's realism and utility.
The results demonstrate the simulator's potential as a training tool for interventional cardiology, providing a realistic and controllable environment for clinicians to refine their TSP skills. Experienced cardiologists tended to cluster their puncture points closer to regions of the FO associated with higher global isotropy index scores, indicating a relationship between experience and optimal puncture localization. The questionnaire analysis revealed that participants generally agreed on the phantom's realistic anatomical representation and ability to accurately visualize the TSP site under fluoroscopic guidance.
The TSP simulator can be incorporated into training programs, offering trainees the opportunity to improve tool handling, spatial coordination, and manual dexterity prior to performing the procedure on patients. Further studies with larger sample sizes and longitudinal assessments are needed to establish the simulator's impact on TSP performance and patient outcomes.
经房间隔穿刺(TSP)是诸如心房颤动(AF)消融和左心耳封堵等左侧心脏介入手术的关键前提条件。尽管TSP是常规操作,但在技术上要求较高且存在并发症风险。本研究提出了一种新颖的、针对患者的拟人化模型,用于TSP模拟训练,可与X射线荧光透视和超声成像配合使用。
TSP模型采用增材制造技术开发,具有可更换的卵圆窝(FO)组件,允许进行多次穿刺而无需更换整个模型。四名心脏病专家和一名心脏病学实习生在模拟器上进行TSP操作,并使用四个指标评估他们的表现:整体各向同性指数、到质心的距离、进行TSP所需的时间,以及一组5级李克特量表问题,以评估临床医生对模型逼真度和实用性的看法。
结果证明了该模拟器作为介入心脏病学训练工具的潜力,为临床医生提供了一个逼真且可控的环境来提升他们的TSP技能。经验丰富的心脏病专家倾向于将穿刺点集中在与更高整体各向同性指数分数相关的FO区域附近,这表明经验与最佳穿刺定位之间存在关联。问卷分析显示,参与者普遍认可模型逼真的解剖结构呈现以及在荧光透视引导下准确可视化TSP部位的能力。
TSP模拟器可纳入训练计划,为学员提供在对患者进行手术前改善工具操作、空间协调和手部灵活性的机会。需要进行更大样本量的进一步研究和纵向评估,以确定模拟器对TSP操作表现和患者预后的影响。