Cunningham Orla, Brady Dr Vivienne
Coombe Hospital, Dolphin's Barn, 8, Dublin, Ireland.
School of Nursing and Midwifery, Trinity College Dublin, 24 D'Olier Street, Dublin 8, D08 XW7X, Ireland; Trinity Centre for Maternity Care Research, Trinity College Dublin, 24 D'Olier Street, Dublin 2, D02 T283, Ireland.
Midwifery. 2023 Oct 14;127:103857. doi: 10.1016/j.midw.2023.103857.
Pregnancy yoga is a holistic practice to support the physiological and psychological changes women experience in pregnancy, with the potential to be offered by mainstream maternity services. Evidence suggests benefits of pregnancy yoga are reduced anxiety and stress, enhanced mood and sleep, with reported improvements in physical and overall wellbeing. Women report that yoga in pregnancy assists in their birth preparation and self-efficacy in labour, with improved labour and birth experience. To date, a Qualitative Evidence Synthesis (QES) of qualitative studies of women's experiences of pregnancy yoga has not been undertaken and accordingly, the literature lacks a high-level synthesis of women's first-hand accounts.
This qualitative systematic review aims to synthesise and present new evidence about women's views and experiences of pregnancy yoga. Qualitative studies reporting women's views and experiences of practising pregnancy yoga as a sole intervention, were eligible for inclusion. Systematic searches of eight academic databases, AMED, ASSIA, CINAHL, EMBASE, MEDLINE, MIDIRS, PsycInfo and Web of Science, accompanied by extensive searches of Grey Literature, and evidence libraries, took place in May 2022. The methodological quality of included studies was formally evaluated, independently, by two reviewers using an adapted quality assessment tool. Data extraction followed and thematic synthesis, using the Thomas and Harden 2008 framework, was the validated method for the development of six analytical themes.
Seven studies, providing the experiences of 92 pregnant women, were included in the review. The methodological quality of the studies was mixed, with three of the seven scoring highly and two scoring medium for weight of evidence. The three key synthesised themes were: Equilibrium; Personal Autonomy in Healthcare; and Connection. There were six analytical subthemes: intuitive knowing, embedding the practice of yoga practice, practical toolkit, holistic care, baby bonding and peer social support.
Synthesis of pregnant women's voices identified what women want - easy access to the holistic benefits of pregnancy yoga; what they recommend - pregnancy yoga provided as mainstream maternity support and what should be provided - pregnancy yoga for all women, not only those who can afford to pay; Paying attention to what women identify as important, brings us closer to a woman-centred maternity service.
孕期瑜伽是一种整体性的练习方式,有助于支持女性在孕期所经历的生理和心理变化,主流产科服务机构有可能提供此项服务。有证据表明,孕期瑜伽的益处包括焦虑和压力减轻、情绪和睡眠改善,身体和整体幸福感也有报道称得到提升。女性表示,孕期瑜伽有助于她们为分娩做准备,并提高分娩时的自我效能感,从而改善分娩体验。迄今为止,尚未对关于女性孕期瑜伽体验的定性研究进行定性证据综合分析(QES),因此,文献中缺乏对女性第一手描述的高层次综合分析。
本定性系统评价旨在综合并呈现有关女性对孕期瑜伽的看法和体验的新证据。将报告女性将练习孕期瑜伽作为唯一干预措施的看法和体验的定性研究纳入其中。2022年5月,对八个学术数据库(AMED、ASSIA、CINAHL、EMBASE、MEDLINE、MIDIRS、PsycInfo和Web of Science)进行了系统检索,并对灰色文献和证据库进行了广泛检索。由两名评审员使用经过改编的质量评估工具独立对纳入研究的方法学质量进行正式评估。随后进行数据提取,并采用托马斯和哈登2008年的框架进行主题综合分析,这是开发六个分析主题的验证方法。
该评价纳入了七项研究,提供了92名孕妇的体验。研究的方法学质量参差不齐,七项研究中有三项证据权重得分高,两项得分中等。三个关键的综合主题是:平衡;医疗保健中的个人自主权;以及联系。有六个分析子主题:直觉认知、融入瑜伽练习、实用工具包、整体护理、母婴联结和同伴社会支持。
综合孕妇的声音,明确了女性想要的东西——轻松获得孕期瑜伽的整体益处;她们的建议——将孕期瑜伽作为主流产科支持提供;以及应该提供的内容——为所有女性提供孕期瑜伽,而不仅仅是那些有能力付费的女性;关注女性认为重要的事情,能让我们更接近以女性为中心的产科服务。