Dervišević Emina, Selmanagić Aida, Milovanović Petar, Zelić-Mihajlović Ksenija
Department of Forensic Medicine, Faculty of Medicine, University of Sarajevo, Sarajevo, Bosnia and Herzegovina.
Department of Tooth Morphology with Dental Anthropology and Forensics, School of Dentistry, University of Sarajevo, Sarajevo, Bosnia and Herzegovina.
Acta Stomatol Croat. 2024 Sep;58(3):209-217. doi: 10.15644/asc58/3/2.
The aim was to test the Belgrade age formula based on the calculation of open apices of two permanent mandibular teeth on a Bosnian children population and compare its accuracy with European formula.
We included 412 panoramic images of children (204 female and 208 male) 7 to 13 years of age. We assessed the performance of both methods (the European formula and the BAF) and compared their results in both sexes.
The results showed a high point of average understanding between the age estimated by chronological age and the European formula (ICC=0.927, 95% CI 0.904-0.944, p<0.001)., BAF also confirmed a high point of agreement with chronological age in boys (ICC=0.941, 95% CI 0.922-0.955, p<0.001) and girls (ICC=0.913, 95% CI 0.886-0.934, p<0.001). BAF was better than the European formula in estimating age in males (0.4448±0.9135 vs. 0.9807±0.9422).
The Belgrade Age Formula (BAF) demonstrates comparable accuracy to the European formula for age determination in Bosnian children, while offering the advantage of being easier and faster to use. This makes the BAF a practical alternative in clinical and research settings where efficiency and reliability are essential.
旨在基于对波斯尼亚儿童群体中两颗恒下颌牙开放根尖的计算来测试贝尔格莱德年龄公式,并将其准确性与欧洲公式进行比较。
我们纳入了412例7至13岁儿童的全景图像(204名女性和208名男性)。我们评估了两种方法(欧洲公式和BAF)的性能,并比较了它们在两性中的结果。
结果显示,按实足年龄估算的年龄与欧洲公式之间的平均一致性较高(ICC = 0.927,95% CI 0.904 - 0.944,p < 0.001)。BAF也证实与男孩(ICC = 0.941,95% CI 0.922 - 0.955,p < 0.001)和女孩(ICC = 0.913,95% CI 0.886 - 0.934,p < 0.001)的实足年龄有较高的一致性。在估算男性年龄方面,BAF优于欧洲公式(0.4448±0.9135对0.9807±0.9422)。
贝尔格莱德年龄公式(BAF)在波斯尼亚儿童年龄测定方面显示出与欧洲公式相当的准确性,同时具有使用更简便、更快的优势。这使得BAF在效率和可靠性至关重要的临床和研究环境中成为一种实用的替代方法。