El Khoury Tanya, Rebeiz Marie-Claire, Abi Zeid Berthe, Mansour Sara, Yared George, El Kak Faysal, Akik Chaza, McCall Stephen J
Faculty of Health Sciences, Center for Research on Population and Health, American University of Beirut, Beirut, Lebanon.
Department of Obstetrics & Gynecology, Lebanese American University, Beirut, Lebanon.
PLOS Glob Public Health. 2024 Nov 4;4(11):e0003853. doi: 10.1371/journal.pgph.0003853. eCollection 2024.
Quality and timely antenatal care is a vital component of pregnancy care for the well-being of mothers and babies. The aim of this study of to assess self-reported obstetricians' adherence to national and international antenatal care guidelines in Lebanon. This cross-sectional study approached all obstetricians registered with the Lebanese Society of Obstetrics and Gynecology and the Lebanese Order of Physicians to participate in an online and telephone-based survey. The study tool included all of the items from the World Health Organization and national guidelines for antenatal care. Obstetricians' self-reported adherence was assessed across five modules including dietary interventions, dietary supplements, antenatal care assessment, fetal growth assessment, and antenatal care preventive measures. A total of 134 obstetricians completed the survey. Overall, adherence was high for most antenatal care guidelines except for providing nutrition services to undernourished pregnant women, screening for intimate partner violence, and providing tetanus vaccines. The number of recommended antenatal care visits (≥8 vs. <8 visits) was higher among obstetricians in Mount Lebanon or Beirut compared to other areas in Lebanon (72.7%vs.48.6%; p-value <0.01). Provision of tetanus or diphtheria, tetanus, and pertussis (DTP) vaccination was lower for obstetricians who provide care for women who pay out-of-pocket compared to obstetricians who provide care to women who use other payment methods (25.3%vs.45.7%; p-value = 0.024). Group B streptococcus screening test and the provision of at least five ultrasounds were higher among obstetricians who provide care in private clinics or clinics in private hospitals compared to clinics in public hospitals or primary healthcare centers (88.8%vs.66.7%; p-value = 0.023) and (83.6%vs.55.6%; p-value = 0.011), respectively. Reinforcing the adherence to all antenatal care guidelines by continuous monitoring of health facilities is crucial for best practice. Subsidies for essential services may be required for those who are unable to afford components of antenatal care.
优质且及时的产前护理是保障母婴健康的孕期护理的重要组成部分。本研究旨在评估黎巴嫩产科医生自我报告的对国家和国际产前护理指南的遵循情况。这项横断面研究联系了所有在黎巴嫩妇产科学会和黎巴嫩医师协会注册的产科医生,邀请他们参与一项基于网络和电话的调查。研究工具涵盖了世界卫生组织和国家产前护理指南中的所有项目。产科医生的自我报告遵循情况在五个模块中进行评估,包括饮食干预、膳食补充剂、产前护理评估、胎儿生长评估和产前护理预防措施。共有134名产科医生完成了调查。总体而言,除了为营养不良的孕妇提供营养服务、筛查亲密伴侣暴力以及提供破伤风疫苗外,大多数产前护理指南的遵循率较高。与黎巴嫩其他地区相比,黎巴嫩山或贝鲁特的产科医生建议的产前检查次数(≥8次与<8次)更多(72.7%对48.6%;p值<0.01)。与为使用其他支付方式的女性提供护理的产科医生相比,为自费女性提供护理的产科医生破伤风或白喉、破伤风和百日咳(DTP)疫苗接种率较低(25.3%对45.7%;p值 = 0.024)。与公立医院或初级医疗保健中心的诊所相比,在私立诊所或私立医院诊所提供护理的产科医生B族链球菌筛查试验以及至少进行五次超声检查的比例更高(分别为88.8%对66.7%;p值 = 0.023)和(83.6%对55.6%;p值 = 0.011)。通过持续监测医疗机构来加强对所有产前护理指南的遵循对于最佳实践至关重要。对于那些无力承担产前护理部分费用的人,可能需要对基本服务提供补贴。