Center for Tropical Medicine, Bernhard Nocht Institute for Tropical Medicine & I. Department of Medicine University Medical Center Hamburg-Eppendorf, Hamburg, Germany.
German Centre for Infection Research, Partner Site Hamburg-Lübeck-Borstel-Riems, Hamburg-Lübeck-Borstel-Riems, Hamburg, Germany.
PLoS Negl Trop Dis. 2024 Nov 6;18(11):e0012610. doi: 10.1371/journal.pntd.0012610. eCollection 2024 Nov.
Filarial pathogens are described to inhabit and affect subcutaneous and lymphatic tissues of the human host. To date, little is known on how much oral health might be affected by filarial infections, even though involvement of the oro-facial region is pathophysiologically possible. Therefore, we conducted this systematic review of the literature to help reduce the current evidence gap. First, we reviewed the existing literature related to oro-facial filariasis and summarized all confirmed cases in detail. Second, we presented the demographic clinical characteristics of published oro-facial filariasis cases using descriptive statistics.
A comprehensive search was conducted using PubMed and Google Scholar to identify scholarly articles on oro-facial filariasis (PROSPERO: CRD42024551237). Clinical trial registries of clinicaltrials.gov and the Pan-African Clinical Trials Registry (PACTR) were checked for ongoing studies on oro-facial filariasis. From clinical articles on filariasis and oro-facial health, patient-specific information was ascertained such as country of diagnosis, age, sex and symptoms of the patient, location of filarial disease manifestation, filarial worm species diagnosis, main clinical diagnosis, as well as main pathology and lastly therapy. Descriptive statistics were computed.
The systematic search was conducted on 18.06.2024. Initially a total of 1,064 publications was identified. No registered study on oro-facial filariasis was found on large clinical trial registers. After sequentially assessing abstracts and full-texts for eligibility, the analysis population was reduced to 68 articles amounting to 111 cases of oro-facial filariasis. Published articles which were identified and ultimately selected consisted solely of case reports, or case series; not a single epidemiological study was found in the published body of literature. Published data on oro-facial filariasis was identified from as early as 1864 until 2022. The median age of oro-facial filariasis cases was 39 years (range: 1 year to 80 years) and evenly distributed between the two sexes (49% [54/110] female and 51% [56/110]; sex not reported for one case). The vast majority of identified cases was on oro-facial dirofilariasis (92% [102/111]), followed by lymphatic filariasis (2.5% [3/111]), lymphatic filariasis with squamous carcinoma (2.5% [3/111]), and lastly by onchocerciasis (1% [1/111]). Although in 34% (38/111) of articles there was no clear description of the main pathology of oro-facial filariasis, all of the remaining 73 articles described nodules or swellings. Asymptomatic manifestations constituted almost 75% (55/73) and only about 25% (18/73) of articles described a symptomatic case.
Although filarial diseases are to date not generally regarded as being associated with oral health problems this assumption might not be justified. This comprehensive systematic review was conducted to detect and collate all published studies on oro-facial filariasis. The fact that only case reports, or case series were identified suggests that this constitutes a neglected field of research. Cases identified in the published literature indicate that the vast majority of published oro-facial, filarial case reports were cases of dirofilariasis. Among the published studies, oro-facial filariasis manifested exclusively as nodules or swellings in different tissue locations. These nodules and swellings were mostly asymptomatic and therefore, cancer is an important differential diagnosis.
丝虫病原体被描述为栖息并影响人体宿主的皮下组织和淋巴组织。迄今为止,尽管口面部区域在病理生理学上可能受到感染,但人们对口腔健康可能受到多大程度的影响知之甚少。因此,我们对文献进行了系统回顾,以帮助缩小当前的证据差距。首先,我们回顾了与口面丝虫病相关的现有文献,并详细总结了所有确诊病例。其次,我们使用描述性统计方法介绍了已发表的口面丝虫病病例的人口统计学临床特征。
使用 PubMed 和 Google Scholar 进行全面检索,以确定有关口面丝虫病的学术文章(PROSPERO:CRD42024551237)。检查临床trials.gov 和泛非临床试验注册处(PACTR)的临床试验注册处,以了解正在进行的口面丝虫病研究。从有关丝虫病和口面健康的临床文章中,确定了患者的具体信息,如诊断国家/地区、年龄、性别和患者症状、丝虫病表现部位、丝虫种类诊断、主要临床诊断以及主要病理学和最后治疗。计算了描述性统计数据。
系统搜索于 2024 年 6 月 18 日进行。最初共确定了 1064 篇出版物。大型临床试验登记处未发现关于口面丝虫病的注册研究。在依次评估摘要和全文的资格后,分析人群减少到 68 篇文章,涉及 111 例口面丝虫病。已确定并最终选择的已发表文章仅包括病例报告或病例系列;发表的文献中没有发现单一的流行病学研究。从 1864 年到 2022 年,已经确定了口面丝虫病的发表数据。口面丝虫病病例的中位年龄为 39 岁(范围:1 岁至 80 岁),性别分布均匀(49%[54/110]为女性,51%[56/110]为男性;一例病例未报告性别)。绝大多数确定的病例为口面类丝虫病(92%[102/111]),其次是淋巴丝虫病(2.5%[3/111])、淋巴丝虫病伴鳞状细胞癌(2.5%[3/111]),最后是盘尾丝虫病(1%[1/111])。尽管在 34%(38/111)的文章中没有明确描述口面丝虫病的主要病理学,但其余 73 篇文章都描述了结节或肿胀。无症状表现占近 75%(55/73),只有约 25%(18/73)的文章描述了有症状的病例。
尽管丝虫病目前一般不被认为与口腔健康问题有关,但这种假设可能没有得到证实。进行这项全面的系统回顾是为了发现和整理所有已发表的口面丝虫病研究。已识别的病例仅为病例报告或病例系列,这表明这是一个被忽视的研究领域。已发表文献中的病例表明,已发表的口面丝虫病病例绝大多数为类丝虫病。在已发表的研究中,口面丝虫病仅表现为不同组织部位的结节或肿胀。这些结节和肿胀大多无症状,因此癌症是一个重要的鉴别诊断。