Borrie Stephanie A, Tetzloff Katerina A, Barrett Tyson S, Lansford Kaitlin L
Department of Communicative Disorders and Deaf Education, Utah State University, Logan.
Department of Communication Science and Disorders, Florida State University, Tallahassee.
Am J Speech Lang Pathol. 2025 Jan 7;34(1):85-96. doi: 10.1044/2024_AJSLP-24-00196. Epub 2024 Nov 6.
Perceptual training offers a promising, listener-targeted option for improving intelligibility of dysarthric speech. Cognitive resources are required for learning, and theoretical models of listening effort and engagement account for a role of listener motivation in allocation of such resources. Here, we manipulate training instructions to enhance motivation to test the hypothesis that increased motivation increases the intelligibility benefits of perceptual training.
Across two data collection sites, which differed with respect to many elements of study design including age of speaker with dysarthria, dysarthria type and severity, type of testing and training stimuli, and participant compensation, 84 neurotypical adults were randomly assigned to one of two training instruction conditions: enhanced instructions or standard instructions. Intelligibility, quantified as percent words correct, was measured before and after training.
Listeners who received the enhanced instructions achieved greater intelligibility improvements from training relative to listeners who received the standard instructions. This result was robust across data collection sites and the many differences in methodology.
This study provides evidence for the role of motivation in improved understanding of dysarthric speech-increasing motivation increases allocation of cognitive resources to the learning process, resulting in improved mapping of the degraded speech signal. This provides empirical support for theoretical models of listening effort and engagement. Clinically, the results show that a simple addition to the training instructions can elevate learning outcomes.
感知训练为提高构音障碍患者言语的可懂度提供了一种有前景的、以听者为目标的方法。学习需要认知资源,而关于听觉努力和参与度的理论模型认为听者动机在这类资源的分配中起作用。在此,我们通过操纵训练指导语来增强动机,以检验动机增强会增加感知训练的可懂度益处这一假设。
在两个数据收集点,84名神经正常的成年人被随机分配到两种训练指导语条件之一:强化指导语或标准指导语。这两个数据收集点在研究设计的许多方面存在差异,包括构音障碍患者的年龄、构音障碍类型和严重程度、测试和训练刺激的类型以及参与者补偿等。在训练前后测量以正确单词百分比量化的可懂度。
与接受标准指导语的听者相比,接受强化指导语的听者从训练中获得了更大的可懂度提高。这一结果在各数据收集点以及方法上的诸多差异中都很稳健。
本研究为动机在提高对构音障碍言语的理解中的作用提供了证据——动机增强会增加对学习过程的认知资源分配,从而改善对退化言语信号的映射。这为听觉努力和参与度的理论模型提供了实证支持。临床上,结果表明在训练指导语中简单增加内容就能提高学习效果。