Wellcome Connecting Science, Wellcome Genome Campus, Hinxton, UK.
Department of Paediatric Haematology and Oncology, Cambridge University Hospitals NHS Foundation Trust, Cambridge, UK.
BMC Med Educ. 2024 Nov 6;24(1):1273. doi: 10.1186/s12909-024-06219-y.
The clinical utility of whole genome sequencing (WGS) in paediatric cancer has been demonstrated in recent years. WGS has been routinely available in the National Health Service (NHS) England for all children with cancer in England since 2021, but its uptake has been variable geographically. To explore the underlying barriers to routine use of WGS in this population across England and more widely in the United Kingdom (UK) and the Republic of Ireland (ROI), a one-day workshop was held in Cambridge, United Kingdom in October 2022.
Following a series of talks, delegates participated in open, round-table discussions to outline local and broader challenges limiting routine WGS for diagnostic work-up for children with cancer in their Principal Treatment Centres (PTCs) and Genomic Laboratory Hubs (GLHs). Within smaller groups, delegates answered structured questions regarding clinical capability, education and training needs, and workforce competence and requirements. Data was recorded, centrally collated, and analysed following the event using thematic analysis.
Sixty participants attended the workshop with broad representation from the 20 PTCs across the UK and ROI and the seven GLHs in England. All healthcare professionals involved in the WGS pathway were represented, including paediatric oncologists, clinical geneticists, clinical scientists, and histopathologists. The main themes highlighted by the group in ensuring equitable access to WGS identified were: lack of knowledge equity between NHS trusts, with a perception of WGS being for research only; and perception of lack of financial support for the clinical process surrounding WGS, including lack of time to take informed consent from patients. The latter also included limited trained staff available for data interpretation, affecting the turnaround time for reporting. Finally, the need for an integrated digital pathway to order, track, and return data to clinicians was highlighted.
At the workshop, the general motivation for including WGS in the diagnostic work up for children with cancer was high throughout the UK, however a perceived lack of resources and education opportunities limit the widespread use of this commissioned assay. This workshop has led to some recommendations to increase access to WGS in this population in England and more widely in the devolved national of the UK and the ROI.
近年来,全基因组测序(WGS)在儿科癌症中的临床实用性已得到证实。自 2021 年以来,英格兰所有癌症儿童均可在英格兰国民保健服务体系(NHS)中常规获得 WGS,但各地的采用情况各不相同。为了探讨在英格兰以及英国(UK)和爱尔兰共和国(ROI)更广泛地区常规使用 WGS 治疗此类人群的潜在障碍,于 2022 年 10 月在英国剑桥举办了为期一天的研讨会。
在一系列演讲之后,代表们参加了公开的圆桌讨论,概述了限制主要治疗中心(PTC)和基因组实验室中心(GLH)常规 WGS 用于儿童癌症诊断工作的当地和更广泛的挑战。在较小的小组中,代表们回答了有关临床能力、教育和培训需求以及劳动力能力和要求的结构化问题。活动结束后,使用主题分析对数据进行记录、集中整理和分析。
共有 60 名参与者参加了研讨会,代表了英国和 ROI 的 20 个 PTC 和英格兰的 7 个 GLH。参与 WGS 途径的所有医疗保健专业人员都有代表,包括儿科肿瘤学家、临床遗传学家、临床科学家和组织病理学家。小组强调确保公平获得 WGS 的主要主题包括:NHS 信托之间缺乏知识公平,人们认为 WGS 仅用于研究;以及 WGS 临床流程缺乏资金支持的看法,包括没有时间从患者处获得知情同意。后者还包括用于数据解释的训练有素的员工有限,这影响了报告的周转时间。最后,强调需要一个集成的数字途径来订购、跟踪和将数据返回给临床医生。
在研讨会上,英国各地普遍有将 WGS 纳入儿童癌症诊断工作的动机,但资源和教育机会的缺乏限制了这种委托检测的广泛使用。本次研讨会提出了一些建议,以增加英格兰以及英国和 ROI 这些地区儿童的 WGS 获得机会。