Docherty John P, Colbert Brett M
Department of Psychiatry, Weill Cornell Medical College, New York, NY, United States.
Medical Scientist Training Program, University of Miami Miller School of Medicine, Miami, FL, United States.
Front Psychiatry. 2024 Oct 23;15:1477543. doi: 10.3389/fpsyt.2024.1477543. eCollection 2024.
The evolution of psychotherapeutic treatments from Freud to digitally administered evidence-based treatments reflects a history of progressive advance. This history is characterized by identification of problems with the current state of the art, followed by solutions inspired and supported by advances in basic science and technology leading to subsequent recognition of other limitations revealed by the new advance. The common thread running through this process is (a) increasing specificity of the psychotherapeutic interventions, (b) increasing evidence of efficacy and safety, (c) increasing integrity and reliability in the delivery of the intervention, (d) increased equality of access, and (e) recognition of the need for regulation to provide protection for the public from unsafe or ineffective products. This evolution of psychotherapeutic treatments, not surprisingly, has been foreshadowed by the precursor history of the evolution of pharmacologic treatment. Although intellectual history is lumpy and does not sort itself into discrete and coherent epochs, such sorting is a useful heuristic for describing the advance of medicine and the therapeutic enterprise. This paper will discuss six successive epochs of psychotherapy. For each it will discuss the problem of the preceding era it sought to solve, the advance it brought to the field, the emerging science and technology that supported that advance, and the precursor development in pharmacological treatments that foreshadowed that epoch of psychotherapy. Finally, it will conclude with some observations about the proximate future.
从弗洛伊德时代的心理治疗方法到数字化管理的循证治疗方法的演变,反映了一个不断进步的历史进程。这段历史的特点是,先指出当前技术水平存在的问题,然后在基础科学和技术进步的启发与支持下找到解决方案,进而发现新进展所揭示的其他局限性。贯穿这一过程的主线包括:(a)心理治疗干预的特异性不断提高;(b)疗效和安全性的证据不断增加;(c)干预实施过程中的完整性和可靠性不断提高;(d)获得治疗的平等性增加;(e)认识到需要进行监管,以保护公众免受不安全或无效产品的侵害。不出所料,心理治疗方法的这种演变在药物治疗的早期历史中已有预兆。尽管知识史是不连续的,不会自动划分为离散且连贯的时期,但这种划分对于描述医学和治疗事业的进步是一种有用的启发式方法。本文将讨论心理治疗的六个连续时期。对于每个时期,将讨论它试图解决的前一个时代的问题、它给该领域带来的进步、支持这一进步的新兴科学和技术,以及预示该心理治疗时期的药物治疗的前期发展。最后,将对近期未来进行一些观察总结。