Chatanaka Miyo K, Diamandis Eleftherios P
Department of Laboratory Medicine and Pathobiology, University of Toronto, Toronto, Canada.
Lunenfeld-Tanenbaum Research Institute, Mount Sinai Hospital, Toronto, Canada.
EJIFCC. 2024 Oct 30;35(3):206-209. eCollection 2024 Oct.
Most circulating cancer and other disease biomarker concentrations increase during disease progression, roughly correlating with tumor burden or disease severity. During the biomarker discovery phase, several studies (some published in high-impact journals) report decreases in serum biomarkers at the time of disease diagnosis or during progression (in comparison to control, non-diseased populations). It is suggested these biomarker decreases between normal and diseased populations may have utility in diagnostics.
We briefly examine if a serum cancer biomarker concentration is likely to decrease as cancer progresses through empirical data.
We propose a simple model, which, if correct, would suggest that in most cases, the biomarker decrease during disease progression could be an artifact or epiphenomenon (thus representing false discovery). Our suggestion is supported by the very few examples of decline of serum biomarkers during cancer development and progression.
The notion that a serum biomarker concentration could be inversely associated with tumor burden seems to be an epiphenomenon.
大多数循环肿瘤及其他疾病生物标志物的浓度在疾病进展过程中会升高,大致与肿瘤负荷或疾病严重程度相关。在生物标志物发现阶段,多项研究(有些发表在高影响力期刊上)报告称,在疾病诊断时或进展期间(与对照的非患病群体相比)血清生物标志物会降低。有人认为,正常人群与患病群体之间这些生物标志物的降低可能在诊断中具有实用价值。
我们通过实证数据简要研究癌症进展时血清癌症生物标志物浓度是否可能降低。
我们提出一个简单模型,若该模型正确,则表明在大多数情况下,疾病进展期间生物标志物的降低可能是一种假象或附带现象(因此代表假阳性发现)。癌症发生和进展期间血清生物标志物下降的极少例子支持了我们的观点。
血清生物标志物浓度可能与肿瘤负荷呈负相关这一观点似乎是一种附带现象。