Coen Stephanie E, Downie Victoria, Follett Lucy, McCaig Steve, Parsons Joanne L
School of Geography, University of Nottingham, Nottingham, UK
UK Sports Institute, Manchester, UK.
Br J Sports Med. 2024 Dec 18;58(24):1505-1517. doi: 10.1136/bjsports-2024-108717.
Women remain at increased risk for some sports injuries, such as anterior cruciate ligament rupture and concussion. This study applied a gendered environmental approach to identify modifiable features of women's sport environments that may contribute to the gendered patterning of sports injuries. Our objectives were to identify features of gendered environments that mattered in athletes' lived experiences and to trace pathways connecting these features to injury.
We employed a creative methodology combining semi-structured interviews with artefact-elicited storytelling and poetic transcription to actively centre women athletes' voices and communicate their experiences in formats intended to stimulate reflection among sport system stakeholders.
Drawing on insights from 20 recently retired women athletes across 11 UK high-performance sports, our reflexive thematic analysis identified five gendered environmental challenges shaping women's injury experiences, risk and outcomes: (1) stereotypes trivialise injury, (2) physiology is all or nothing, (3) the 'ideal' female athlete, (4) in/visible inequities and (5) uneven power dynamics. Within these gendered environmental challenges, we identified mechanisms through which challenges manifest in the everyday experiences of athletes, highlighting these as potential points to disrupt the gendered environments-to-injury pathway.
Our findings provide an evidence-based framework for categorising and addressing gendered environmental challenges in women's sport. Interventions to reconfigure the gendered status quo within sport should be embedded as part of injury prevention strategies.
女性在一些运动损伤方面的风险仍然较高,比如前交叉韧带断裂和脑震荡。本研究采用性别化环境方法,以确定女性运动环境中可能导致运动损伤性别模式的可改变特征。我们的目标是识别在运动员生活经历中重要的性别化环境特征,并追踪将这些特征与损伤联系起来的途径。
我们采用了一种创造性的方法,将半结构化访谈与人工制品引发的故事讲述和诗意转录相结合,以积极地将女性运动员的声音置于中心位置,并以旨在激发体育系统利益相关者反思的形式传达她们的经历。
借鉴来自英国11项高水平运动项目中20名近期退役的女性运动员的见解,我们的反思性主题分析确定了塑造女性损伤经历、风险和结果的五个性别化环境挑战:(1)刻板印象使损伤被轻视,(2)生理因素被视为唯一因素,(3)“理想”女性运动员,(4)显性/隐性不平等,以及(5)不均衡的权力动态。在这些性别化环境挑战中,我们确定了挑战在运动员日常经历中显现的机制,将这些机制作为破坏从性别化环境到损伤途径的潜在切入点。
我们的研究结果为分类和应对女性运动中的性别化环境挑战提供了一个基于证据的框架。重新配置体育领域性别现状的干预措施应作为预防损伤策略的一部分加以实施。