Sands Madeline, Tidwell Ben, Aunger Robert
University of Arizona College of Medicine, Tucson, AZ, USA.
WASH Research Lead at World Vision and Adjunct Assistant Professor at UNC, Wilmington, NC, USA.
Eval Rev. 2025 Jun;49(3):487-510. doi: 10.1177/0193841X241299854. Epub 2024 Nov 12.
This study tested a 'wise' intervention (quick prompt of a specific psychological mec) in acute care hospital units to improve nurses' hand hygiene compliance (HHC). A multiple baseline design in two medical-surgical teaching hospitals in the United States. Hand hygiene data was collected using an electronic compliance monitoring system with sensors placed in doorways and on corresponding soap and alcohol-based hand rub dispensers. The outcome measure was the proportion of opportunities in which HH was undertaken by staff per week in each unit. A quick-and-easy psychological prime to reinvigorate professional identity. Interrupted time series analysis using a quasi-Poisson regression model with statistical process control charts for each unit. A statistically significant increase in HHC rates that was sustained for months post-intervention. However, the patterns by unit were not statistically significant once temporal trends were considered. Other factors, such as the unit type and the use of incentives could have impacted the results. These analyses suggest that the aggregate impact should not be taken as evidence of intervention effectiveness. This study therefore cannot be considered to have provided a strong foundation for use of a 'wise' intervention, despite its relatively small financial, logistical and psychological cost.
本研究在急症护理医院病房测试了一种“明智”干预措施(快速提示一种特定的心理机制),以提高护士的手部卫生依从性(HHC)。在美国两家内科-外科教学医院采用多基线设计。使用电子依从性监测系统收集手部卫生数据,该系统的传感器安装在门口以及相应的肥皂和酒精洗手液分配器上。结果指标是每个病房每周工作人员进行手部卫生的机会比例。采用一种快速简便的心理启动方式来重振职业认同感。使用准泊松回归模型并为每个病房绘制统计过程控制图进行中断时间序列分析。干预后手部卫生依从率有统计学意义的显著提高,并持续了数月。然而,一旦考虑时间趋势,各病房的模式就没有统计学意义了。其他因素,如病房类型和激励措施的使用,可能影响了结果。这些分析表明,总体影响不应被视为干预有效性的证据。因此,尽管该研究的财务、后勤和心理成本相对较小,但不能认为它为使用“明智”干预措施提供了有力依据。