Meade Gabriela, Pham Nha Trang Thu, Clark Heather M, Duffy Joseph R, Whitwell Jennifer L, Josephs Keith A, Utianski Rene L
Department of Neurology, Mayo Clinic, Rochester, MN.
Department of Radiology, Mayo Clinic, Rochester, MN.
J Speech Lang Hear Res. 2024 Dec 9;67(12):4651-4662. doi: 10.1044/2024_JSLHR-24-00283. Epub 2024 Nov 15.
Speakers with primary progressive apraxia of speech (PPAOS) have an insidious onset of motor speech planning/programming difficulties. As the disease progresses, the apraxia of speech (AOS) becomes more severe and a co-occurring dysarthria often emerges. Here, longitudinal data from speakers with phonetic- and prosodic-predominant PPAOS are used to characterize the progression of their motor speech impairment, including the development of dysarthria and mutism.
Data are presented from 52 speakers who had PPAOS at enrollment (i.e., progressive AOS in the absence of aphasia, cognitive, or other neurologic symptoms). Twenty-one had predominantly phonetic features, whereas 31 had primarily prosodic features. All participants underwent a comprehensive motor speech evaluation at their enrollment visit and each annual return visit, with a median of three visits per participant.
Almost 25% of the speakers with PPAOS presented with dysarthria at their enrollment visit (median disease duration of 3.65 years), whereas more than 70% of them had developed dysarthria by their last visit (median disease duration of 6.85 years). Neither the likelihood to develop dysarthria nor the disease duration at which it was detected differed significantly between the phonetic and prosodic groups. However, muteness emerged sooner for speakers with phonetic-predominant PPAOS; the median disease duration at which they became mute was 1.5 years shorter than for their prosodic counterparts.
Clinically, these results facilitate more accurate prognostication of motor speech symptoms in speakers with PPAOS, allowing for timely introduction of alternative means of communication. The results also support the differentiation between progressive AOS and dysarthria as distinct motor speech disorders that often co-occur in these individuals.
原发性进行性言语失用症(PPAOS)患者隐匿起病,存在运动性言语规划/编程困难。随着疾病进展,言语失用症(AOS)会变得更加严重,且常并发构音障碍。在此,利用以语音和韵律为主的PPAOS患者的纵向数据来描述其运动性言语障碍的进展情况,包括构音障碍和缄默症的发展。
数据来自52名入组时患有PPAOS的患者(即无失语、认知或其他神经症状的进行性AOS)。21名主要表现为语音特征,而31名主要表现为韵律特征。所有参与者在入组就诊时以及每次年度复诊时均接受了全面的运动性言语评估,每位参与者的就诊次数中位数为3次。
近25%的PPAOS患者在入组就诊时(疾病持续时间中位数为3.65年)出现了构音障碍,而超过70%的患者在最后一次就诊时(疾病持续时间中位数为6.85年)出现了构音障碍。语音组和韵律组在发生构音障碍的可能性以及检测到构音障碍的疾病持续时间方面均无显著差异。然而,以语音为主的PPAOS患者出现缄默症的时间更早;他们出现缄默症的疾病持续时间中位数比韵律组患者短1.5年。
在临床上,这些结果有助于更准确地预测PPAOS患者的运动性言语症状,以便及时引入替代沟通方式。这些结果还支持将进行性AOS和构音障碍区分开来,它们是这些个体中经常同时出现的不同运动性言语障碍。