University of the West of England, School of Health and Social Wellbeing, Bristol, England, UK.
School of Healthcare Sciences, Cardiff University, Wales, UK.
Eur J Paediatr Neurol. 2024 Nov;53:166-173. doi: 10.1016/j.ejpn.2024.10.012. Epub 2024 Nov 10.
To determine the effectiveness of integrated hip surveillance pathways on pain, function and quality of life (QOL) in children with Cerebral Palsy (CP).
A systematic literature review, designed, conducted and reported using the Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta-Analyses.
confirmed CP diagnosis, management under recognised international hip surveillance pathways, outcome measures of hip displacement plus at least one other relevant to pain, function or QOL.
100 articles were identified. 12 full text articles were screened, and four were included. Reduced range of movement was associated with hip pain in children with CP. Increasing age, Gross Motor Function Classification Score (GMFCS) and migration percentage (MP) were associated with increased hip pain. General health declined with increased age. Increased MP and GMFCS level were associated with interruption to activities of daily living.
Outcomes relating to function and QOL are under-researched in the current integrated hip surveillance pathway evidence-base. Wider outcomes related to function and QOL need to be included to capture the wider impact on children who are at risk of hip dislocation.
Increased pain was associated with reduced joint range and increased migration percentage. Pain also increased with greater age and Gross Motor Function Classification Score. Early orthopaedic intervention for hip displacement may not successfully mitigate pain. Effectiveness of integrated pathways on function and quality of life is under-evidenced. Studies investigating integrated pathways and holistic outcomes are needed to inform practice.
评估综合性髋关节监测路径对脑瘫患儿疼痛、功能和生活质量(QOL)的疗效。
采用系统综述的方法,设计、实施并报告,严格按照系统综述和荟萃分析的首选报告项目进行。
明确的脑瘫诊断,采用公认的国际髋关节监测路径进行管理,髋关节移位的结果测量指标,加上至少一个与疼痛、功能或 QOL 相关的其他指标。
共确定了 100 篇文章。对 12 篇全文进行了筛选,最终纳入 4 篇。髋关节活动范围减小与脑瘫患儿的髋关节疼痛有关。年龄增长、粗大运动功能分级(GMFCS)和移行百分比(MP)与髋关节疼痛增加相关。年龄增长与一般健康状况下降有关。MP 和 GMFCS 水平增加与日常生活活动中断有关。
目前综合性髋关节监测路径证据基础中,与功能和 QOL 相关的结果研究不足。需要纳入更广泛的功能和 QOL 相关结果,以捕捉对有髋关节脱位风险的儿童的更广泛影响。
增加的疼痛与关节活动范围减小和移行百分比增加有关。疼痛也随着年龄和粗大运动功能分级的增加而增加。髋关节移位的早期矫形干预可能并不能成功缓解疼痛。综合性路径对功能和生活质量的疗效证据不足。需要研究综合性路径和整体结果,以为实践提供信息。