Boylu Muhammed Emin, Görmez Aynur, Turan Şenol, Yeşilkaya Ümit Haluk, Boylu Fatma Betül, Duran Alaattin
Department of Psychiatry, Council of Forensic Medicine, Ministry of Justice, İstanbul, Türkiye.
Department of Health Law, Graduate School of Social Sciences, İstanbul Medipol University, Türkiye.
Autism Res. 2025 Jan;18(1):110-121. doi: 10.1002/aur.3275. Epub 2024 Nov 18.
The forensic and clinical need for better understanding of criminal offending in adults with ASD is increasingly recognized. To date, few studies have examined the differences and similarities between criminal offenders with and without ASD with respect to demographics, offending profiles, and clinical characteristics. This study, conducted in Turkey, is the first to conduct such as comparison using a national database of forensic files. Computerized search of the forensic records of 11,853 adults assessed between January 1, 2012, and January 1, 2022, for criminal responsibility by the Turkish Council of Forensic Medicine found 74 adults diagnosed with ASD; they ranged in age from 18 to 40. [Correction added after first online publication on 04 December 2024. The value 11,583 has been revised to 11,853.] The demographic, clinical, and offending characteristics of these adults were compared to 100 adults without ASD selected from the remaining 11,779 records based on age (18-40 years) and year of assessment (10 from each year). The ASD group was younger, more likely to be unemployed and not living on their own. The ASD group was more likely to have co-morbid intellectual disability, ADHD, and OCD, while the non-ASD group was more likely to have co-morbid personality disorders, The ASD group was more likely to commit unplanned simple (non-penetrative) sexual and violent offenses against strangers; the non-ASD group was more likely to commit planned, qualified (penetrative) crimes against known persons. Impulsivity and manipulability were more often contributory in persons with ASD; revenge was more often contributory in persons without ASD. Adults with ASD were more likely to commit crimes on social media. In conclusion, this study found that adult offenders with and without ASD differed in demographics, psychiatric co-morbidities, and types of offending behaviors. These differences may have implications for the prevention of criminal offending in persons with ASD and addressing their needs once they are in the criminal justice system.
人们越来越认识到法医学和临床方面对于更好地理解患有自闭症谱系障碍(ASD)的成年人犯罪行为的需求。迄今为止,很少有研究考察患有和未患有ASD的成年罪犯在人口统计学、犯罪概况和临床特征方面的异同。这项在土耳其开展的研究是首次使用国家法医档案数据库进行此类比较。通过计算机检索土耳其法医委员会在2012年1月1日至2022年1月1日期间评估刑事责任的11853名成年人的法医记录,发现74名成年人被诊断患有ASD;他们的年龄在18岁至40岁之间。[在2024年12月4日首次在线发表后添加的更正。数值11583已修订为11853。] 将这些成年人的人口统计学、临床和犯罪特征与从其余11779份记录中根据年龄(18 - 40岁)和评估年份(每年10名)挑选出的100名未患有ASD的成年人进行比较。ASD组更年轻,更有可能失业且不独自生活。ASD组更有可能患有智力残疾、注意力缺陷多动障碍(ADHD)和强迫症等共病,而非ASD组更有可能患有共病性人格障碍。ASD组更有可能对陌生人实施无计划的简单(非侵入性)性犯罪和暴力犯罪;非ASD组更有可能对熟人实施有计划的、严重的(侵入性)犯罪。冲动性和易操纵性在患有ASD的人中更常成为犯罪的促成因素;报复在未患有ASD的人中更常成为犯罪的促成因素。患有ASD的成年人更有可能在社交媒体上犯罪。总之,这项研究发现,患有和未患有ASD的成年罪犯在人口统计学、精神疾病共病情况和犯罪行为类型方面存在差异。这些差异可能对预防患有ASD的人的犯罪行为以及在他们进入刑事司法系统后满足其需求具有启示意义。