Gagarine Maria, Cañedo-Ayala Mara, Cook Vanessa, Discepola Marie-Nicole, Guillot Genevieve, Leader David M, Lim Mathew Awt, Yap Tami, Furst Daniel E, Gietzen Amy, Lapointe McKenzie Jo-Ann, Van Pelt Shelley, Vidiricaire Louise, Carrier Marie-Eve, Krishnan Ankur, Tao Lydia, Kwakkenbos Linda, Thombs Brett D
Lady Davis Institute for Medical Research, Jewish General Hospital, Montreal, QC, Canada.
Department of Epidemiology, Biostatistics and Occupational Health, McGill University, Montreal, QC, Canada.
J Scleroderma Relat Disord. 2024 May 24:23971983241252899. doi: 10.1177/23971983241252899.
Limited research on oral health in systematic sclerosis poses a significant challenge for people with systematic sclerosis and health care professionals. We conducted a scoping review to map existing research on oral health-related quality of life in systematic sclerosis across domains including (1) oral manifestations or symptoms, (2) functional consequences, (3) psychosocial aspects, (4) associated patient factors and (5) self-care and management considerations.
We searched MEDLINE, EMBASE, SCOPUS and CINAHL databases to 10 March 2023 for studies on oral health in people with systematic sclerosis. Study data were mapped into pre-specified domains of oral health-related quality of life, subtopics and types of research and reported in tabular form.
Of 1460 unique studies reviewed, 91 were eligible and included in the scoping review; of these, 69 (76%) were published as full-text versions, 72 (79%) were from Europe or North America, and 63 (69%) included ⩽50 participants. Only 1 study had >200 participants (N = 382). By domains, 85 (93%) studies reported aspects of oral manifestations or symptoms, with the most common subtopics being oral opening and mandibular function, sicca, periodontitis and soft tissue changes and pathology; 36 (40%) studies provided information on associated patient factors, 23 (25%) on self-care and management, 19 (21%) on psychosocial aspects and 6 (7%) on functional consequences. No studies related to interventions included >50 participants.
Most studies on oral health in systematic sclerosis report on manifestations or symptoms, and there are relatively few studies on other important domains. Most studies have been conducted with small samples. Updated systematic reviews should evaluate the quality of existing evidence in domains where enough studies have been done. Large, well-conducted primary studies are needed to address knowledge gaps across domains, including studies that test approaches for supporting oral self-care, improving routine professional care and addressing major disability-causing manifestations.
系统性硬化症患者口腔健康方面的研究有限,这给系统性硬化症患者和医护人员带来了重大挑战。我们进行了一项范围综述,以梳理系统性硬化症患者口腔健康相关生活质量在以下领域的现有研究:(1)口腔表现或症状,(2)功能后果,(3)心理社会方面,(4)相关患者因素,以及(5)自我护理和管理考量。
我们检索了MEDLINE、EMBASE、SCOPUS和CINAHL数据库,截至2023年3月10日,查找关于系统性硬化症患者口腔健康的研究。研究数据被映射到口腔健康相关生活质量的预先指定领域、子主题和研究类型,并以表格形式呈现。
在审查的1460项独特研究中,91项符合条件并纳入范围综述;其中,69项(76%)以全文形式发表,72项(79%)来自欧洲或北美,63项(69%)纳入的参与者≤50名。只有1项研究的参与者超过200名(N = 382)。按领域划分,85项(93%)研究报告了口腔表现或症状方面,最常见的子主题是张口和下颌功能、干燥症、牙周炎以及软组织变化和病理;36项(40%)研究提供了相关患者因素的信息,23项(25%)涉及自我护理和管理,19项(21%)涉及心理社会方面,6项(7%)涉及功能后果。没有关于干预措施的研究纳入的参与者超过50名。
大多数关于系统性硬化症患者口腔健康的研究报告的是表现或症状,而关于其他重要领域的研究相对较少。大多数研究的样本量较小。更新的系统综述应评估在已有足够研究的领域中现有证据的质量。需要开展大规模、实施良好的原始研究,以填补各领域的知识空白,包括测试支持口腔自我护理、改善常规专业护理以及应对主要致残表现的方法的研究。