Loftus Randy W, Brindeiro Carmen T, Dexter Franklin, Parra Michelle C, Hwang Soyun M, Wanta Brendan, Szeluga Debra J, Hadder Brent A, Seering Melinda S, Charnin Jonathan E
Anesthesiology and Perioperative Medicine, Mayo Clinic, Rochester, USA.
Microbiology, RDB Bioinformatics, Coralville, USA.
Cureus. 2024 Oct 16;16(10):e71612. doi: 10.7759/cureus.71612. eCollection 2024 Oct.
The relative importance of different ultraviolet-C (UV-C) emitter configurations on the attenuation of vegetative bacterial and fungal pathogens has not been assessed. We hypothesized that emitter configuration would impact the efficacy of UV-C attenuation of and ( pathogens.
American Type Culture Collection (ATCC) (ATCC 6538) and (ATCC MYA-5001 carriers (ReadyNowTM Test Carriers, Stratix Labs Corporation, Saint Paul, MN) were mounted on an aluminum stand along with three calibrated radiometers (International Light Technologies model ILT1270, Peabody, MA). Five UV-C emitter configurations were assessed, including three emitters with a triangular configuration about the stand and each rotating 360° (1), one emitter facing the stand and rotating 360° (2), three emitters facing the stand in a linear configuration and each rotating 5° (3), one emitter facing the stand and rotating 5° (4), and one emitter facing the stand and rotating 90° (5). Three serial experiments were conducted. The first experiment involved the establishment of the minimally effective irradiation dose (mean and standard deviation mJ/cm) required to achieve no growth (6-log reduction (LR)) with direct exposure to pathogen carriers positioned at the center of the lamp. We then assessed the relative efficacy of delivery of the minimally effective dose via the five emitter configurations in attenuating polycarbonate and textured pathogen carriers. Polycarbonate carriers were positioned at 25.5 and 69.5 inches from the floor and oriented vertically to the emitters. Textured plastic pathogen carriers were positioned at 47.5 or 58.5 inches from the floor and with a 45° or horizontal orientation to the emitters. Standard carriers (1"x0.9") were used for both pathogens and large carriers (1"x3") for ,the latter to address the potential for cell clustering.
With standard carriers, the minimally effective dose was 27.01± 0.15 mJ/cm for but was not achieved for . The minimally effective dose for large carriers was 596.62 ± 27.98 mJ/cm. With standard carriers, all configurations achieved a >6 log reduction for and none achieved a >6 log reduction for All configurations achieved a > 6 log reduction when 596.62 ± 27.98 mJ/cm was delivered to large carriers. Changing to textured plastic carriers (standard for and large for ) and varying height (47.5-69.5 inches) from the floor and orientation to the emitters (45° and horizontal), the mean ± standard deviation for and log reductions with delivery of the minimally effective dose was 4.44 ± 2.02, 2.58 ± 2.37, 3.55 ± 2.67, 2.33 ± 2.47, and 3.00 ± 2.64 for configurations one through five, respectively. Configuration one achieved a significantly greater LR than configurations two (adjusted P = 0.0018) and four (adjusted P = 0.023). There were 22% (6/27) of sites ≥ 100 colony-forming units (CFU) following cleaning but before UV-C vs. 0% (0/27) of sites ≥ 100 CFU after surface disinfection cleaning and nine minutes of configuration three UV-C treatment (P = 0.023).
The choice of UV-C emitter configuration can impact and attenuation when there is indirect exposure to the pathogen. Emitter configuration should be considered as an important parameter for future UV-C technological assessments.
不同的紫外线-C(UV-C)发射器配置对营养型细菌和真菌病原体衰减的相对重要性尚未得到评估。我们假设发射器配置会影响UV-C对金黄色葡萄球菌和白色念珠菌病原体的衰减效果。
将美国典型培养物保藏中心(ATCC)的金黄色葡萄球菌(ATCC 6538)和白色念珠菌(ATCC MYA-5001)载体(ReadyNowTM测试载体,Stratix Labs Corporation,明尼苏达州圣保罗)与三个校准辐射计(国际光技术公司型号ILT1270,马萨诸塞州皮博迪)一起安装在铝制支架上。评估了五种UV-C发射器配置,包括围绕支架呈三角形配置且每个旋转360°的三个发射器(1)、一个面向支架并旋转360°的发射器(2)、呈线性配置面向支架且每个旋转5°的三个发射器(3)、一个面向支架并旋转5°的发射器(4)以及一个面向支架并旋转90°的发射器(5)。进行了三个系列实验。第一个实验涉及确定直接暴露于位于灯中心的病原体载体时实现无生长(6对数减少(LR))所需的最小有效辐照剂量(平均和标准偏差mJ/cm²)。然后,我们评估了通过五种发射器配置递送最小有效剂量在衰减聚碳酸酯和有纹理的病原体载体方面的相对效果。聚碳酸酯载体放置在距离地面25.5英寸和69.5英寸处,并垂直于发射器定向。有纹理的塑料病原体载体放置在距离地面47.5英寸或58.5英寸处,并与发射器呈45°或水平方向。标准载体(1英寸×0.9英寸)用于两种病原体,大载体(1英寸×3英寸)用于白色念珠菌,后者用于解决细胞聚集问题。
对于标准载体,金黄色葡萄球菌所需的最小有效剂量为27.01±0.15 mJ/cm²,但白色念珠菌未达到该剂量。大的白色念珠菌载体的最小有效剂量为596.62±27.98 mJ/cm²。对于标准载体,所有配置对金黄色葡萄球菌均实现了>6对数减少,而对白色念珠菌均未实现>6对数减少。当向大的白色念珠菌载体递送596.62±27.9这个内容似乎不完整,请补充完整后继续向我提问。98 mJ/cm²时,所有配置均实现了>6对数减少。更换为有纹理的塑料载体(金黄色葡萄球菌为标准载体,白色念珠菌为大载体)并改变距离地面的高度(47.5 - 69.5英寸)以及与发射器的方向(45°和水平),在递送最小有效剂量时,配置一至五的金黄色葡萄球菌和白色念珠菌对数减少的平均值±标准偏差分别为4.44±2.02、2.58±2.37、3.55±2.67、2.33±2.47和3.00±2.64。配置一实现的对数减少显著大于配置二(调整后P = 0.0018)和配置四(调整后P = 0.023)。清洁后但在UV-C照射前,有22%(6/27)的位点≥100菌落形成单位(CFU),而在表面消毒清洁和配置三的UV-C处理九分钟后,≥100 CFU的位点为0%(0/27)(P = 0.023)。
当病原体间接暴露时,UV-C发射器配置的选择会影响金黄色葡萄球菌和白色念珠菌的衰减。发射器配置应被视为未来UV-C技术评估的一个重要参数。