Heng Lena, McAdams Stephen
Schulich School of Music, McGill University, Montreal, QC, Canada.
Music Sci. 2024 Dec;28(4):675-702. doi: 10.1177/10298649241237775. Epub 2024 Mar 18.
Timbre has been identified as a potential component in the communication of affect in music. Although its function as a carrier of perceptually useful information about sound source mechanics has been established, less is understood about whether and how it functions as a carrier of information for communicating affect in music. To investigate these issues, listeners trained in Chinese and Western musical traditions were presented with Phrases, Measures, and Notes of recorded excerpts interpreted with a variety of affective intentions by performers on instruments from the two cultures. Results showed greater accuracy and more extreme responses in Chinese musician listeners and lowest accuracy in nonmusicians suggesting that musical training plays a role in listeners' decoding of affective intention. Responses were more differentiated and more accurate with more musical information. Excerpts were also analyzed to determine acoustic features that are correlated with timbre characteristics. Temporal, spectral, and spectrotemporal attributes were consistently used in judging affective intent in music, suggesting purposeful use of these properties by listeners. Comparison between listeners' use of acoustic features reveals a greater number of shared features between Western musicians and nonmusicians compared to Chinese musicians for valence, although the three groups shared more features for arousal. How timbre is utilized in musical communication appears to be different across musical traditions, and valence responses seem to be more culture-specific and arousal responses more similar across cultures.
音色已被确认为音乐情感传达中的一个潜在要素。尽管其作为有关声源机制的感知有用信息载体的功能已得到确立,但对于它是否以及如何作为音乐情感传达的信息载体发挥作用,人们了解得较少。为了研究这些问题,我们让接受过中西方音乐传统训练的听众聆听由来自两种文化的乐器演奏者以各种情感意图诠释的录制片段中的乐句、小节和音符。结果显示,中国音乐家听众的准确性更高,反应更极端,而非音乐家的准确性最低,这表明音乐训练在听众对情感意图的解码中发挥着作用。音乐信息越多,反应就越有差异且越准确。我们还对片段进行了分析,以确定与音色特征相关的声学特征。时间、频谱和谱-时间属性在判断音乐情感意图时一直被使用,这表明听众在有目的地利用这些属性。听众对声学特征的使用比较表明,与中国音乐家相比,西方音乐家和非音乐家在效价方面共享的特征更多,不过这三组在唤醒方面共享的特征更多。在音乐交流中音色的运用方式在不同音乐传统中似乎有所不同,效价反应似乎更具文化特异性,而唤醒反应在不同文化中更相似。