Bart Yossi, Horgan Rebecca, Saade George, Sibai Baha M
Division of Maternal-Fetal Medicine, Department of Obstetrics, Gynecology and Reproductive Sciences, McGovern Medical School at UTHealth, Houston, TX (Bart and Sibai).
Division of Maternal-Fetal Medicine, Department of Obstetrics and Gynecology, Eastern Virginia Medical School, Norfolk, VA (Horgan and Saade).
Am J Obstet Gynecol MFM. 2025 Jan;7(1):101554. doi: 10.1016/j.ajogmf.2024.101554. Epub 2024 Nov 17.
The research and implementation process for a new screening test should involve two steps. First, one has to demonstrate that the test can predict a certain outcome or appropriately stratify the patients based on risk for the outcome. The second step requires evidence of clinical utility. The Food and Drug Administration has approved screening tests for risk stratification or progression of preeclampsia despite the absence of data on clinical utility. Introduction into clinical practice and eventual integration into the standard of care might follow quickly, making a clinical utility trial challenging to accomplish. This manuscript provides an overview of the research and regulatory pathways used for screening and diagnostic tests in medicine in general and obstetrics in particular. For illustration purposes, we review the relevant data gathered so far regarding tests that are promoted for prediction, risk stratification, and progression of preeclampsia. We then discuss the importance of proving clinical utility before introducing tests into clinical practice and the potential unintended consequences of adoption prior to proving clinical utility. VIDEO ABSTRACT.
一项新的筛查试验的研究与实施过程应包括两个步骤。首先,必须证明该试验能够预测某种结果,或者根据结果风险对患者进行适当分层。第二步需要临床效用的证据。尽管缺乏临床效用数据,但美国食品药品监督管理局已批准用于子痫前期风险分层或病情进展的筛查试验。这些试验可能很快就会引入临床实践并最终融入医疗标准,这使得进行临床效用试验颇具挑战性。本手稿概述了一般医学尤其是产科中用于筛查和诊断试验的研究及监管途径。为便于说明,我们回顾了目前收集到的有关子痫前期预测、风险分层及病情进展相关试验的相关数据。然后我们讨论了在将试验引入临床实践之前证明临床效用的重要性,以及在证明临床效用之前采用试验可能产生的意外后果。视频摘要。