Bojorquez Ietza, Arévalo Marcel, Chávez Ana L, Gómez-Osorio Rosa N, Rodríguez-Chavez César, Leyva René, Gittinger Rachel, Bustamante Nirma D
Department of Population Studies, El Colegio de la Frontera Norte, Tijuana, Baja California, Mexico.
Program on Migration and Poverty, Facultad Latinoamericana de Ciencias Sociales (FLACSO)-Guatemala, Guatemala City, Guatemala.
PLOS Glob Public Health. 2024 Nov 20;4(11):e0003685. doi: 10.1371/journal.pgph.0003685. eCollection 2024.
Cross-border use of health services has been studied mainly as travel from high- to low- and middle-income countries ("medical tourism"). The movement between low- and middle-income countries has been less studied. The objectives were; 1) to describe the frequency, types of services used, and health needs associated with cross-border utilization of health services at the Mexico-Guatemala border; 2) to explore the drivers of cross-border use among people living in this area. We conducted a mixed-methods study. The quantitative component was a probability survey of border crossers (March to April 2023, analysis sample n = 4,733, weighted n = 74,228). The qualitative component consisted of 28 semi-structured interviews with users and providers of health services living close to the international border (May-June 2023). Descriptive results were obtained separately and triangulated. 3.8% (CI 95% 3.1,4.7) in the sample were crossing the border for the purpose of seeking health care or purchasing medicines, 7.4% (CI 95% 5.9,9.2) had crossed the border in the past year to seek care, and 21.8% (CI 95% 18.8,25.1) to purchase medicines. According to quantitative and qualitative results, those living in Mexico were more likely to cross the border to seek care than those living in Guatemala, independent of country of birth, while crossing to Mexico to buy medicine was more common than crossing to Guatemala for the same reason. Public and private services were accessed in similar proportions, the former mostly for preventive care (vaccination) and the latter for specialized care. Qualitative results showed that the main drivers of cross-border health care use were perceived quality and geographical availability. The main drivers of cross-border buying of medicines were affordability and perceived quality. The use of private services can benefit the local economy. The use of public services for preventive purposes can be an asset for health promotion.
跨境使用医疗服务的研究主要集中在从高收入国家到中低收入国家的旅行(“医疗旅游”)。中低收入国家之间的人员流动则较少受到研究。本研究的目的是:1)描述墨西哥与危地马拉边境地区跨境使用医疗服务的频率、服务类型以及相关健康需求;2)探究该地区居民跨境使用医疗服务的驱动因素。我们开展了一项混合方法研究。定量部分是对边境过境者的概率调查(2023年3月至4月,分析样本n = 4733,加权n = 74228)。定性部分包括对居住在国际边境附近的医疗服务使用者和提供者进行的28次半结构化访谈(2023年5月至6月)。分别获得描述性结果并进行三角互证。样本中有3.8%(95%置信区间3.1, 4.7)出于寻求医疗护理或购买药品的目的过境,7.4%(95%置信区间5.9, 9.2)在过去一年中为寻求医疗护理而过境,21.8%(95%置信区间18.8, 25.1)为购买药品而过境。根据定量和定性结果,无论出生国如何,居住在墨西哥的人比居住在危地马拉的人更有可能跨境寻求医疗护理,而出于相同原因前往墨西哥买药比前往危地马拉更常见。使用公共和私人服务的比例相似,前者主要用于预防性护理(疫苗接种),后者用于专科护理。定性结果表明,跨境医疗护理使用的主要驱动因素是感知质量和地理可及性。跨境购买药品的主要驱动因素是可承受性和感知质量。使用私人服务可使当地经济受益。将公共服务用于预防目的可为健康促进提供助力。