Viottini Elena, Ferrero Alice, Albanesi Beatrice, Acquaro Johnny, Bulfone Giampiera, Condemi Francesca, D'Accolti Donatella, Massimi Azzurra, Mattiussi Elisa, Sturaro Roberta, Conti Alessio, Dimonte Valerio
Department of Biomedicine and Prevention, University of Rome "Tor Vergata", 00133 Rome, Italy.
Department of Public Health and Pediatrics, University of Torino, 10126 Torino, Italy.
Nurs Rep. 2024 Nov 13;14(4):3488-3504. doi: 10.3390/nursrep14040254.
BACKGROUND/OBJECTIVES: Higher education institutions must improve the attractiveness and retention of the nursing profession to address the widespread shortage. This pilot multimethod study aimed to preliminarily understand the relationship between motivations for enrolment and dropout among first-year undergraduate nursing students.
A two-step approach was conducted among first-year nursing students from five Italian universities involving: (a) a baseline quantitative online survey collecting their characteristics and motivations for enrolment; (b) a follow-up semi-structured interview qualitative data collection among students who dropped out. Descriptive and inferential statistics were used to describe the motivations for enrolment and differences between universities. Dropout motivations emerged from inductive content analysis, with data categorisation according to Urwin's framework.
A total of 759 students completed the online survey. Primary motivations for enrolment included the desire to be useful (88.8%), help suffering people (84.3%), and find employment (74.2%); 22.3% cited unsuccessful admission to another university as motivation for enrolment. Of the 141 students who discontinued, 31 were interviewed (22%). Eleven categories and three themes were identified. More than half of the participants dropped out due to interest in other courses and lack of aptitude, while a smaller number cited personal circumstances. Other motivations for dropout were related to negative learning environments or feelings and difficulties related to course characteristics.
This study provides an initial insight into these complex phenomena that will be instrumental in understanding data from an Italian multicenter cohort study. The findings can inform recommendations and strategies to strengthen the future nursing workforce.
背景/目标:高等教育机构必须提高护理专业的吸引力并留住人才,以应对普遍存在的人才短缺问题。这项多方法试点研究旨在初步了解本科护理专业一年级学生入学动机与辍学之间的关系。
对来自五所意大利大学的护理专业一年级学生采用了两步法,包括:(a)进行一项基线定量在线调查,收集他们的特征和入学动机;(b)对辍学学生进行后续半结构化访谈以收集定性数据。使用描述性和推断性统计来描述入学动机以及各大学之间的差异。通过归纳内容分析得出辍学动机,并根据厄温的框架对数据进行分类。
共有759名学生完成了在线调查。入学的主要动机包括渴望有所作为(88.8%)、帮助受苦的人(84.3%)以及找到工作(74.2%);22.3%的人将未能被另一所大学录取作为入学动机。在141名退学的学生中,对31人进行了访谈(22%)。确定了11个类别和3个主题。超过一半的参与者因对其他课程感兴趣和缺乏天赋而退学,而少数人提到了个人情况。其他退学动机与负面的学习环境或与课程特点相关的感受及困难有关。
本研究对这些复杂现象提供了初步见解,这将有助于理解来自意大利多中心队列研究的数据。研究结果可为加强未来护理人才队伍建设的建议和策略提供参考。