Geriatric Medicine Research, Nova Scotia Health, Nova Scotia, Canada.
Division of Kinesiology, Dalhousie University, Nova Scotia, Canada.
Can Med Educ J. 2024 Nov 13;15(5):95-112. doi: 10.36834/cmej.77065. eCollection 2024 Nov.
Providing physical activity counselling and prescribing exercise increases patients' activity and cardiorespiratory fitness, but healthcare providers experience challenges in promoting activity to patients. Implementing educational intervention during medical training may be an effective strategy to promote physical activity and exercise counselling/prescriptions. The purpose of this review was to evaluate the impact of educational interventions on medical students' physical activity counselling and exercise prescription perceptions and practices.
Systematic review procedures were registered in PROSPERO (ID# CRD42022331755) prior to conducting the study. Studies were included if they conducted an educational intervention to medical students or residents aimed at improving activity practices. Sources were searched in May of 2022 and included Scopus, EMBASE, MEDLINE, CINAHL, and Academic Search Premier ( = 3412 citations without duplicates). The National Institutes of Health quality assessment tools were used.
Fifteen interventions were included. The average quality of the included controlled trials ( 6) and pre-post studies with no control group ( = 9) were 5.0±1.5/12 and 6.2±1.3/14, respectively. Most studies ( = 4/6) that reported the total number of medical students providing activity counselling to patients before and after receiving intervention observed improvements in exercise counselling behaviours. Eleven of twelve, and ten of eleven studies reported increases in confidence and perceptions toward various features of exercise counselling and physical activity promotion, respectively.
Despite the heterogeneous nature of intervention designs, this review supports that relatively brief interventions using a structured lecture format incorporated into curriculum promote acute improvements in medical students' perceptions and confidence in providing exercise counselling, albeit based on low-moderate study quality.
提供身体活动咨询和开运动处方可以增加患者的活动量和心肺功能健康,但医疗保健提供者在向患者宣传活动方面存在挑战。在医学培训中实施教育干预可能是促进身体活动和运动咨询/处方的有效策略。本研究旨在评估教育干预对医学生身体活动咨询和运动处方认知和实践的影响。
在进行研究之前,系统评价程序已在 PROSPERO(ID#CRD42022331755)中注册。如果教育干预针对医学生或住院医师,旨在改善活动实践,则纳入研究。研究源在 2022 年 5 月进行搜索,包括 Scopus、EMBASE、MEDLINE、CINAHL 和 Academic Search Premier(=3412 条无重复引文)。使用了美国国立卫生研究院的质量评估工具。
纳入了 15 项干预措施。纳入的对照试验(=6)和无对照组的前后研究(=9)的平均质量分别为 5.0±1.5/12 和 6.2±1.3/14。大多数(=4/6)报告在接受干预前后向患者提供身体活动咨询的医学生总数的研究观察到运动咨询行为的改善。11/12 和 10/11 项研究分别报告了对运动咨询和身体活动促进各个方面的信心和认知的增加。
尽管干预设计的性质存在异质性,但本综述支持相对简短的干预措施,使用结构化讲座形式融入课程,可促进医学生提供运动咨询的认知和信心的急性改善,尽管基于低到中等质量的研究。