Brentnall Jennie, Rossiter Laura, Judd Belinda, Cowley Emma, McCormick Keith, Turk Ruth, Thackray Debbie
University of Sydney, Sydney, NSW, 2006, Australia.
University of Southampton, Southampton, SO17 1BJ, England.
Adv Simul (Lond). 2024 Nov 27;9(1):45. doi: 10.1186/s41077-024-00316-0.
Positive outcomes of simulation programmes to prepare students for placement are widely noted. However, few studies adequately describe considerations for designing allied health placement simulations. There exists a conceptual framework to guide such simulation design, which draws on theory and educational expertise but to date lacks varied stakeholder perspectives. This study aimed to identify implications for the design of allied health placement simulation from participants' experiences of a simulation-based, interprofessional, novice placement preparation programme.
Occupational therapy, physiotherapy and podiatry students finishing their first year of study were offered a 1-week intensive interprofessional simulation immediately before their first placement. Focus groups in the following weeks allowed participants to discuss their experiences of the programme, preparation for student placements, and recommendations. These were transcribed and interpreted using reflexive thematic analysis and then abductively related to the conceptual framework.
In total, 22 participants broadly representative of the simulation programme participants contributed to separate focus groups with domestic-enrolled students (n = 7), international students (n = 5), external practice educators (n = 6), and simulated participants (n = 4). Inductive reflexive thematic analysis generated six themes: (i) engaging learning environment, (ii) realism and relevance, (iii) student confidence and communication, (iv) international students' needs, (v) recommendations to facilitate further preparation for placement, and (vi) importance of preparation to engage in simulation. All participant groups were invested in the programme and highlighted learning opportunities. An immersive and relatable experience with active participation contributed to confidence and communication skill development. International students noted needs pertaining to cultural and language expectations. Other participant recommendations related to the equity of opportunities and specific preparation for placement student-educator interactions. Finally, every participant group noted features of effective preparation for simulation-based education.
Relating these findings abductively to the literature and conceptual frameworks, this study highlights simulation design considerations for learner needs assessment, engagement, realism, psychological safety, and challenge to prepare learners for their first clinical placement. Specific implications for adequately preparing all participant groups, design considerations for the needs of culturally diverse students, and balancing interprofessional and discipline-specific learning are highlighted from a lived experience viewpoint. Future research may engage greater stakeholder co-design in simulation-based education.
模拟项目在帮助学生为实习做准备方面取得的积极成果已得到广泛关注。然而,很少有研究充分描述设计健康相关专业实习模拟时的考量因素。存在一个指导此类模拟设计的概念框架,该框架借鉴了理论和教育专业知识,但迄今为止缺乏不同利益相关者的观点。本研究旨在从参与者对一个基于模拟的跨专业新手实习准备项目的体验中,确定对健康相关专业实习模拟设计的启示。
职业治疗、物理治疗和足病学专业完成第一年学业的学生在首次实习前立即参加了为期1周的强化跨专业模拟。在接下来的几周里,通过焦点小组让参与者讨论他们对该项目的体验、实习准备情况以及建议。对这些讨论进行转录,并使用反思性主题分析进行解读,然后与概念框架进行归纳关联。
共有22名广泛代表模拟项目参与者的人员参与了分别针对国内注册学生(n = 7)、国际学生(n = 5)、外部实习教育工作者(n = 6)和模拟参与者(n = 4)的焦点小组。归纳反思性主题分析产生了六个主题:(i)引人入胜的学习环境,(ii)真实性和相关性,(iii)学生信心和沟通,(iv)国际学生的需求,(v)促进进一步实习准备的建议,以及(vi)参与模拟准备的重要性。所有参与者群体都参与了该项目并强调了学习机会。积极参与的沉浸式且相关的体验有助于信心和沟通技能的发展。国际学生指出了与文化和语言期望相关的需求。其他参与者的建议涉及机会公平以及实习学生与教育工作者互动的具体准备。最后,每个参与者群体都提到了基于模拟的教育有效准备的特点。
将这些发现与文献和概念框架进行归纳关联,本研究突出了模拟设计在学习者需求评估、参与度、真实性、心理安全以及挑战方面的考量因素,以便让学习者为首次临床实习做好准备。从实际经验的角度强调了充分准备所有参与者群体的具体启示、针对文化背景多样学生需求的设计考量,以及平衡跨专业和特定学科学习的问题。未来的研究可能会让更多利益相关者共同参与基于模拟的教育设计。