Agyare Veronica Adwoa, Poku Collins Atta, Baafi Samuel, Berchie Eunice, Attafuah Priscilla Yeye Adumoah
Akenten Appiah-Menka University of Skills Training and Entrepreneurial Development (AAMUSTED), Kumasi, Ghana.
Department of Nursing, School of Nursing and Midwifery, KNUST, Kumasi, Ghana.
BMC Med Educ. 2025 Apr 21;25(1):586. doi: 10.1186/s12909-025-07155-1.
As most nursing academics have suggested, training student nurses to be professionals with all the qualities of a good nurse requires time and attention to detail. Students in the nursing program exhibit enthusiasm and dedication to succeeding in their chosen field from the moment they are accepted into the school. This comes with varied expectations regarding teaching, learning, and relationships with educators. It is essential how teaching and learning are affected by the student-nursing-tutor interaction, which significantly impacts learning, growth, and professional development. This study explored the evolving relationship between students and educators in nursing institutions from the perspective of students.
The study used an exploratory, descriptive qualitative approach to understand the phenomenon. Participants in the final year of their training were recruited, and a focused group discussion was conducted. Thirty participants, all students, were involved in the study. Data saturation determined the sample size. All the interactions were audio-recorded and transcribed verbatim. Transcriptions were analysed using thematic analysis.
The findings revealed two main themes, initial relationship and subsequent relationship, with related subthemes: uncertainty regarding the initial relationship, welcoming relationship, influencers of subsequent relationship and adaptational relationship. Students mentioned that they are admitted into nursing institutions with personal expectations and preconceived notions about educators, leading to interaction uncertainty. Some of these notions were confirmed as their expectations were unmet. It was reported that students experienced a welcoming first interaction. However, the subsequent relationship was influenced by educators' attitudes and teaching approaches. Overall, students described the student-tutor relationship as adaptational.
This study provides actionable recommendations for improving nursing education practices in Ghana. Findings reiterate the impact of unhealthy student-educator relationships on learning and teaching outcomes; therefore, educators should deliberately enhance their relationships by properly socialising students into the profession and acting as role models. Educators should regularly reflect on student interactions and enhance their skills for better output.
正如大多数护理学界人士所指出的,要将护生培养成具备优秀护士所有品质的专业人员,需要时间和对细节的关注。护理专业的学生从被学校录取的那一刻起,就展现出对在所选领域取得成功的热情和奉献精神。这伴随着对教学、学习以及与教育工作者关系的各种期望。护生与导师的互动如何影响教学和学习至关重要,因为这会对学习、成长和专业发展产生重大影响。本研究从学生的角度探讨了护理机构中护生与教育工作者之间不断演变的关系。
本研究采用探索性、描述性定性方法来理解这一现象。招募了处于培训最后一年的参与者,并进行了焦点小组讨论。共有30名参与者,均为学生,参与了该研究。数据饱和确定了样本量。所有互动均进行了录音并逐字转录。转录内容采用主题分析法进行分析。
研究结果揭示了两个主要主题,即初始关系和后续关系,以及相关子主题:初始关系的不确定性、欢迎关系、后续关系的影响因素和适应关系。学生们提到,他们带着对教育工作者的个人期望和先入之见进入护理机构,这导致了互动的不确定性。其中一些观念因期望未得到满足而得到证实。据报告,学生们经历了一次令人欢迎的首次互动。然而,后续关系受到教育工作者态度和教学方法的影响。总体而言,学生们将护生与导师的关系描述为适应性的。
本研究为改善加纳的护理教育实践提供了可操作的建议。研究结果重申了不健康的护生与教育工作者关系对教学成果的影响;因此,教育工作者应通过适当地引导学生进入该专业并以身作则,有意识地加强他们之间的关系。教育工作者应定期反思与学生的互动,并提升自身技能以获得更好的教学效果。