A significant portion of human cancers utilize a recombination-based pathway, Alternative Lengthening of Telomeres (ALT), to extend telomeres. To gain further insights into this pathway, we developed a high-throughput imaging-based screen named TAILS (Telomeric ALT Localization Screen), to identify genes that either promote or inhibit ALT activity. Screening over 1000 genes implicated in DNA transactions, TAILS revealed both well-established and novel ALT modulators. We have identified new factors that promote ALT, such as the nucleosome-remodeling factor CHD4 and the chromatin reader SGF29, as well as factors that suppress ALT, including the RNA helicases DDX39A/B, the replication factor TIMELESS, and components of the chromatin assembly factor CAF1. Our data indicate that defects in histone deposition significantly contribute to ALT-associated phenotypes. Based on these findings, we demonstrate that pharmacological treatments can be employed to either exacerbate or suppress ALT-associated phenotypes.