Zararsiz Gözde Ertürk, Lintelmann Jutta, Cecil Alexander, Kirwan Jennifer, Poschet Gernot, Gegner Hagen M, Schuchardt Sven, Guan Xue Li, Saigusa Daisuke, Wishart David, Zheng Jiamin, Mandal Rupasri, Adams Kendra, Thompson J Will, Snyder Michael P, Contrepois Kevin, Chen Songjie, Ashrafi Nadia, Akyol Sumeyya, Yilmaz Ali, Graham Stewart F, O'Connell Thomas M, Kalecký Karel, Bottiglieri Teodoro, Limonciel Alice, Pham Hai Tuan, Koal Therese, Adamski Jerzy, Kastenmüller Gabi
Institute of Computational Biology, Helmholtz Zentrum München - German Research Center for Environmental Health, Neuherberg, Germany.
Department of Biostatistics, Erciyes University School of Medicine, Kayseri, Turkey.
bioRxiv. 2024 Nov 14:2024.11.13.619447. doi: 10.1101/2024.11.13.619447.
Metabolomics and lipidomics are pivotal in understanding phenotypic variations beyond genomics. However, quantification and comparability of mass spectrometry (MS)-derived data are challenging. Standardised assays can enhance data comparability, enabling applications in multi-center epidemiological and clinical studies. Here we evaluated the performance and reproducibility of the MxP Quant 500 kit across 14 laboratories. The kit allows quantification of 634 different metabolites from 26 compound classes using triple quadrupole MS. Each laboratory analysed twelve samples, including human plasma and serum, lipaemic plasma, NIST SRM 1950, and mouse and rat plasma, in triplicates. 505 out of the 634 metabolites were measurable above the limit of detection in all laboratories, while eight metabolites were undetectable in our study. Out of the 505 metabolites, 412 were observed in both human and rodent samples. Overall, the kit exhibited high reproducibility with a median coefficient of variation (CV) of 14.3 %. CVs in NIST SRM 1950 reference plasma were below 25 % and 10 % for 494 and 138 metabolites, respectively. To facilitate further inspection of reproducibility for any compound, we provide detailed results from the in-depth evaluation of reproducibility across concentration ranges using Deming regression. Interlaboratory reproducibility was similar across sample types, with some species-, matrix-, and phenotype-specific differences due to variations in concentration ranges. Comparisons with previous studies on the performance of MS-based kits (including the AbsoluteIDQ p180 and the Lipidyzer) revealed good concordance of reproducibility results and measured absolute concentrations in NIST SRM 1950 for most metabolites, making the MxP Quant 500 kit a relevant tool to apply metabolomics and lipidomics in multi-center studies.
代谢组学和脂质组学对于理解基因组学之外的表型变异至关重要。然而,基于质谱(MS)的数据定量和可比性具有挑战性。标准化检测可以提高数据的可比性,使其能够应用于多中心流行病学和临床研究。在此,我们评估了MxP Quant 500试剂盒在14个实验室中的性能和重现性。该试剂盒使用三重四极杆质谱对来自26种化合物类别的634种不同代谢物进行定量。每个实验室对12个样本进行了分析,包括人血浆和血清、脂血血浆、NIST SRM 1950以及小鼠和大鼠血浆,均进行了三次重复分析。634种代谢物中有505种在所有实验室中均可检测到,且高于检测限,而有8种代谢物在我们的研究中未检测到。在505种代谢物中,有412种在人和啮齿动物样本中均被观察到。总体而言,该试剂盒表现出高重现性,变异系数(CV)中位数为14.3%。在NIST SRM 1950参考血浆中,494种和138种代谢物的CV分别低于25%和10%。为便于进一步检查任何化合物的重现性,我们提供了使用戴明回归对不同浓度范围的重现性进行深入评估的详细结果。不同实验室间的重现性在不同样本类型中相似,但由于浓度范围的差异,存在一些物种、基质和表型特异性差异。与先前关于基于质谱的试剂盒(包括AbsoluteIDQ p180和Lipidyzer)性能的研究进行比较,结果显示,对于大多数代谢物,在NIST SRM 1950中重现性结果和测量的绝对浓度具有良好的一致性,这使得MxP Quant 500试剂盒成为在多中心研究中应用代谢组学和脂质组学的相关工具。