Galeone M, Stock F, Moise G, Cacioli D, Benazzi E, Riva A
Pharmatherapeutica. 1986;4(7):445-56.
Sixty out-patients with acute or sub-acute irritable colon were randomly allocated to receive a single intravenous dose of 50 mg tiropramide, 50 mg trimebutine maleate or 10 mg octilonium bromide. Before and after injection, multiple colonic manometry was performed, monitoring tonus, intensity and frequency of sinusoid contraction waves, transitories and vibrations, as well as the voluntary contraction capacity. Significant variations in tonus were not observed with any drug, but, while tiropramide left unmodified the voluntary contractile ability, a significant inhibition was observed with trimebutine and octilonium. The overall power of spontaneous colonic contractions did not vary significantly with tiropramide, whereas some decrease was observed with trimebutine, and a substantial one with octilonium. Moreover, while with tiropramide and, to a lesser extent, with trimebutine there was a significant redistribution of muscular power so as to increase phasic propulsion waves and to decrease the ineffective transitory and vibrational contractions, with octilonium only a decreased wave amplitude was recorded without alteration of the frequency of transient spasms. Based on these observations, tiropramide was evaluated as being at least as effective an antispasmodic as octilonium and at least as effective a synchronizer as trimebutine, while setting itself aside from both reference drugs as it was the only one to act contemporarily as both an antispasmodic and a synchronizer.
60例急性或亚急性肠易激综合征门诊患者被随机分配,分别接受单次静脉注射50毫克替罗哌隆、50毫克马来酸曲美布汀或10毫克溴化奥替溴铵。注射前后进行多次结肠测压,监测张力、正弦收缩波的强度和频率、短暂性收缩和振动,以及自主收缩能力。使用任何一种药物均未观察到张力有显著变化,但是,替罗哌隆未改变自主收缩能力,而曲美布汀和溴化奥替溴铵则观察到显著抑制作用。替罗哌隆对结肠自发收缩的总体功率没有显著影响,而曲美布汀使其有所降低,溴化奥替溴铵则使其大幅降低。此外,替罗哌隆以及在较小程度上曲美布汀可使肌肉力量发生显著重新分布,从而增加阶段性推进波并减少无效的短暂性收缩和振动性收缩,而溴化奥替溴铵仅记录到波幅降低,瞬态痉挛频率未改变。基于这些观察结果,替罗哌隆被评估为至少与溴化奥替溴铵一样有效的解痉药,并且至少与曲美布汀一样有效的同步剂,同时它又与两种对照药物不同,因为它是唯一同时兼具解痉药和同步剂作用的药物。