Tang Ziqing, Long Xuan, Wang Kai, Berger Klaus, Zhang Yunquan, Mayvaneh Fatemeh
School of Public Health, Wuhan University of Science and Technology, Wuhan 430065, China.
Wuhan Third Hospital (Tongren Hospital of Wuhan University), Wuhan 430060, China.
Ecotoxicol Environ Saf. 2024 Dec;288:117414. doi: 10.1016/j.ecoenv.2024.117414. Epub 2024 Nov 29.
Maternal ambient fine particulate matter (PM) has been linked with fetal low birthweight (LBW), while national causal evidence is limited, particularly in low- and middle-income countries.
We used nationwide registry-based birth records of 3839531 singleton livebirths, with maternal age (MA) between 15 and 49 years, across 31 provinces in Iran from 2013 through 2018. Monthly gridded concentrations of ambient PM during entire pregnancy were estimated through validated spatiotemporal models. We adopted traditional logistic/linear regression and double robust model (DRM) based on generalized propensity scores (GPS) to evaluate associations of maternal PM exposure with LBW risk and birthweight change. MA-specific exposure-response functions were investigated using restricted cubic splines in both traditional and casual inference models. PM-attributable LBW burden were parallelly estimated, under the scenarios of achieving counterfactual exposure levels of multiple WHO interim targets.
A total of 228655 LBW births were identified, and mean birthweight of was 3187 g. Both traditional and causal modelling approaches yielded consistently positive associations of maternal PM exposure with increased LBW risk and reduced birthweight, but marginally larger effect estimates were seen under GPS-based DRM analyses. Specifically, a 10-μg/m increase in ambient PM during the entire pregnancy was associated with the odds of 1.071 (95% confidence interval: 1.066, 1.076) for LBW and reduced birthweight of 8.9 (8.4, 9.4) g in GPS-based DRM analysis. MA-stratified analyses suggested non-linear exposure-response relationships of PM exposure with both LBW (P <0.001) risk and birthweight change (P <0.001) over the exposure range of 17-104 μg/m, with notably steeper slopes at low concentrations (<37.3 μg/m). According to GPS-based DRM analysis, achieving the interim target level 1-3 of annual PM (i.e., 35, 25, and 15 μg/m) could avoid 5.5%-32.6% of overall LBW infants and birthweight loss of 7.0-57.6 g per livebirth during 2013-2018 in Iran.
Our findings provided nationwide evidence of causality for elevated LBW risk and birthweight loss associated with maternal PM exposure in Iran. Improving air quality through multisectoral efforts may avoid dramatic LBW burden to promote neonatal health later in life.
母亲孕期环境细颗粒物(PM)与胎儿低出生体重(LBW)有关,但全国性的因果证据有限,尤其是在低收入和中等收入国家。
我们使用了基于伊朗全国登记处的3839531例单胎活产出生记录,母亲年龄(MA)在15至49岁之间,涵盖2013年至2018年伊朗31个省份。通过经过验证的时空模型估算整个孕期环境PM的月度网格化浓度。我们采用基于广义倾向评分(GPS)的传统逻辑/线性回归和双重稳健模型(DRM)来评估母亲PM暴露与LBW风险和出生体重变化之间的关联。在传统和因果推断模型中,使用受限立方样条研究特定MA的暴露-反应函数。在实现多个世界卫生组织临时目标的反事实暴露水平的情况下,并行估算PM导致的LBW负担。
共识别出228655例低出生体重儿,平均出生体重为3187克。传统和因果建模方法均一致显示母亲PM暴露与LBW风险增加和出生体重降低呈正相关,但在基于GPS的DRM分析中效应估计值略大。具体而言,在基于GPS的DRM分析中,整个孕期环境PM每增加10μg/m³,LBW的比值比为1.071(95%置信区间:1.066,1.076),出生体重降低8.9(8.4,9.4)克。MA分层分析表明,在17-104μg/m³的暴露范围内,PM暴露与LBW风险(P<0.001)和出生体重变化(P<0.001)均呈非线性暴露-反应关系,在低浓度(<37.3μg/m³)时斜率明显更陡。根据基于GPS的DRM分析,在2013-2018年期间,伊朗实现年度PM的临时目标水平1-3(即35、25和15μg/m³)可避免5.5%-32.6%的总体低出生体重儿,且每例活产出生体重减轻7.0-57.6克。
我们的研究结果提供了伊朗全国范围内母亲PM暴露与LBW风险升高和出生体重降低之间因果关系的证据。通过多部门努力改善空气质量可能避免巨大的LBW负担,以促进新生儿后期健康。