El-Tallawy Salah N, Pergolizzi Joseph V, Amlih Haneen F, Fairaq Moaaz M, Awaleh Fouad I, Alsubaie Abdullah T, Shaheen Issam S, Al-Kayyal Yusra S, Ahmed Rania S, Ali Wegdan A
Anesthesia, King Khalid University Hospital, College of Medicine, King Saud University, Riyadh, SAU.
Anesthesia and Pain Management, Faculty of Medicine, Cairo University, Cairo, EGY.
Cureus. 2024 Oct 31;16(10):e72773. doi: 10.7759/cureus.72773. eCollection 2024 Oct.
Cesarean section (CS) is associated with moderate to severe pain that may delay recovery and interfere with the mother's ability to take care of the newborn. This clinical study aimed to evaluate different analgesic protocols for postoperative pain management after CS.
The study included 300 parturients scheduled for CS and classified into five equal groups as follows: general anesthesia (GA group), GA plus transversus abdominis plane (TAP) block (GA+TAP group), spinal anesthesia (SA) plus intrathecal fentanyl (ITF group), SA plus fentanyl + TAP block (ITF+TAP group), and SA plus intrathecal morphine (ITM group). Multimodal analgesia was added to all groups in the form of paracetamol 1 g/6 hours intravenously (IV), lornoxicam (8 mg/8 hours/IV), in addition to rescue opioid analgesia (morphine or oxycodone 4 mg/IV) upon the patient's request. Primary outcomes included pain assessments by numerical rating scale (NRS), worst and least pain scores, and time in maximum pain. Secondary outcomes included time to first request of analgesia, total opioid consumption, patient request for additional analgesia, function, and satisfaction scores. Possible side effects and neonatal Apgar scores were recorded at five and 10 minutes.
The results showed a significant difference between the study groups regarding pain relief. The best pain relief, lowest worst pain, least pain, and total opioid consumption were reported by the ITM group, followed by ITF+TAP, GA+TAP, then SA, and GA groups (p < 0.05). The lower percentage of time in the worst pain and the longest time to the first request of analgesia were reported with ITM and ITF+TAP groups followed by the ITF group and GA+TAP group. In contrast, the longest time spent in the worst pain and the shortest duration until the first request of analgesia was observed in the GA group (p < 0.05). The best function scores were observed with ITF+TAP and then ITM, while the highest satisfaction scores were reported with ITM, ITF+TAP followed by SA and GA+TAP, and the lowest scores were observed in the GA group (p < 0.001 and p < 0.005, respectively). Side effects such as itching, nausea, and vomiting were significantly higher in the ITM group when compared to the other groups (p < 0.05). There were no significant differences between the study groups regarding the Apgar scores at five and 10 minutes (p = 0.271 and 0.760).
Bilateral TAP block has the potential to effectively enhance postoperative analgesia and reduce the need for systemic opioids after both GA and SA. Compared to ITF, ITM provides a higher quality and longer duration of analgesia with minimal analgesic-related side effects. Further studies to find an optimal analgesic protocol with few to no side effects are warranted.
剖宫产(CS)会导致中度至重度疼痛,这可能会延迟恢复并影响母亲照顾新生儿的能力。本临床研究旨在评估剖宫产术后疼痛管理的不同镇痛方案。
该研究纳入了300名计划行剖宫产的产妇,并将其分为五组,每组人数相等,具体如下:全身麻醉(GA组)、全身麻醉加腹横肌平面(TAP)阻滞(GA+TAP组)、脊髓麻醉(SA)加鞘内注射芬太尼(ITF组)、脊髓麻醉加芬太尼+TAP阻滞(ITF+TAP组)以及脊髓麻醉加鞘内注射吗啡(ITM组)。所有组均以静脉注射对乙酰氨基酚1 g/6小时、氯诺昔康(8 mg/8小时/静脉注射)的形式添加多模式镇痛,此外,根据患者需求给予补救性阿片类镇痛药(吗啡或羟考酮4 mg/静脉注射)。主要结局包括采用数字评分量表(NRS)进行的疼痛评估、最严重和最轻疼痛评分以及最大疼痛持续时间。次要结局包括首次请求镇痛的时间、阿片类药物总消耗量、患者请求额外镇痛的情况、功能和满意度评分。在5分钟和10分钟时记录可能的副作用和新生儿阿氏评分。
结果显示,各研究组在疼痛缓解方面存在显著差异。ITM组报告的疼痛缓解效果最佳、最严重疼痛程度最低、最轻疼痛程度最低且阿片类药物总消耗量最少,其次是ITF+TAP组、GA+TAP组,然后是SA组和GA组(p<0.05)。ITM组和ITF+TAP组报告的最严重疼痛持续时间百分比更低,首次请求镇痛的时间最长,其次是ITF组和GA+TAP组。相比之下,GA组观察到最严重疼痛持续时间最长,首次请求镇痛的持续时间最短(p<0.05)。ITF+TAP组然后是ITM组观察到最佳功能评分,而ITM组、ITF+TAP组报告的满意度评分最高,其次是SA组和GA+TAP组,GA组的满意度评分最低(分别为p<0.001和p<0.005)。与其他组相比,ITM组的瘙痒、恶心和呕吐等副作用明显更高(p<0.05)。各研究组在5分钟和10分钟时的阿氏评分无显著差异(p=0.271和0.760)。
双侧TAP阻滞有可能有效增强全身麻醉和脊髓麻醉后的术后镇痛效果,并减少全身阿片类药物的需求。与ITF相比,ITM提供更高质量和更长持续时间的镇痛,且镇痛相关副作用最小。有必要进行进一步研究以找到几乎无副作用的最佳镇痛方案。