Zhao X, Chen Y, Hu Y, Xu Y, Wang Y, Lü D, Wan C, Sun Y, Duan L, Wang W, Huang S
Institute of Plant Protection, Jiangxi Academy of Agricultural Sciences, Nanchang, Jiangxi 330200, China.
Co-first authors.
Zhongguo Xue Xi Chong Bing Fang Zhi Za Zhi. 2024 Nov 12;36(5):441-449. doi: 10.16250/j.32.1915.2024120.
To evaluate the molluscicidal effects and costs of spraying 20% suspension concentrate of pyricloben-zuron sulphate (SCPS) with drones against in paddy environments, so as to provide insights into the extensive applications of pyriclobenzuron against .
On July 2022, a paddy field was selected from Nanchang City, Jiangxi Province as the study area, and 72 independent rectangular plots measuring 2 m × 1 m were allocated in the study area, with 1 m interval between each plot, and 20 snails gently placed in each plot. The activity of 25% wettable powder of pyriclobenzuron sulphate (WPPS) by manual spraying at doses of 0.50, 1.00, 2.00 g/m and 4.00 g/m against was tested in 54 plots, and manual spraying of 50% wettable powder of niclosamide ethanolamine salt (WPNES) at a dose of 0.10 g/m served as a chemical control, while manual spraying of the same volume of clean water served as a blank control, with 9 plots in each group. The activity of SCPS against was tested in the remaining 18 plots. Based on the molluscicidal tests of WPPS, the molluscicidal effect of SCPS by manual spraying at doses of 0.20, 0.30, 0.40 g/m and 0.50 g/m against was evaluated, and manual spraying of WPNES at a dose of 0.10 g/m served as a chemical control, while manual spraying of the same volume of clean water served as a blank control, with three plots in each group. On July 2023, 14 paddy fields with a mean living density of > 5 snails/m were selected from Yujiang District, Yingtan City, Jiangxi Province for molluscicidal tests. Based on the molluscicidal effect of pyriclobenzuron against in plots, the molluscicidal effects of WPPS by manual spraying at doses of 0.25, 0.50 g/m and 1.00 g/m and manual applications of WPPS at dose of 0.25, 0.50, 1.00 g/m and 2.00 g/m mixed with soil were tested, and manual spraying of 0.10 g/m WPNES served as a chemical control group, while manual spraying of the same volume of clean water served as a blank control, with one paddy field in each group. Based on the effect of pyriclobenzuron against in plots, the activity of SCPS sprayed with drones at doses of 0.25 g/m and 0.50 g/m mixed in water at 2 kg/667 m and 4 kg/667 m was tested against , and spraying of the same volume of clean water with drones served as a blank control. All snails were captured 3 days and 7 days following chemical treatment in plots and paddy fields and identified for survival, and the mortality and corrected mortality of snails were estimated. In addition, the areas of chemical treatment, amount of molluscicide use and labor costs of chemical treatment were estimated in molluscicidal tests in paddy fields, and the costs of chemical treatment for an area covering 667 m by drones and manual applications were calculated.
The mortality of snails was all 100% in plots 3 days and 7 days following spraying WPPS at doses of 0.50, 1.00, 2.00 g/m and 4.00 g/m, and the mortality rates of snails were 66.67% to 100.00% 3 days post-treatment with SCPS at various doses (χ = 277.897, < 0.05) and 76.67% to 100.00% 7 days post-treatment (χ = 274.206, < 0.05). The mortality rates of snails were 98.19% to 100.00% 3 days post-treatment with WPPS at various doses in paddy fields. There was a significant difference in the mortality of snails among WPPS treatment groups and controls (χ = 270.778, < 0.05), and there were no significant differences between WPPS treatment groups and the chemical control group (all values > 0.05), while there were significant differences in the mortality of snails between WPPS treatment groups and the blank control group (all values < 0.05). The mortality rates of snails were 89.83% to 95.31% 3 days post-treatment with SCPS at various doses sprayed with drones, and there was a significant difference in the mortality of snails among SCPS treatment groups and the blank control group (χ = 1 132.892, < 0.05). There were no significant differences in the mortality of snails among SCPS treatment groups or water mixture groups (all values > 0.05), and there were significant differences in the mortality of snails between SCPS treatment groups and the blank control group (all values < 0.05). The mortality rates of snails were 94.62% to 100.00% 7 days post-treatment with SCPS at various doses sprayed with drones, and there was a significant difference in the mortality of snails among SCPS treatment groups and the blank control group (χ = 1 266.932, < 0.05), with the highest mortality found following spraying 0.50 g/m SCPS mixed in 2 kg/667 m water with drones ( < 0.05). The costs of snail control by drones and manually were 35.85 Yuan/667 m and 43.33 Yuan/667 m; however, the snail control efficiency was 6.67 times higher by drones than by manual applications.
SCPS sprayed with drones is highly active against snails in paddy fields. SCPS sprayed with drones is highly efficient and low in cost for snail control in paddy fields, beaches and river courses.
评估用无人机喷洒20%硫酸吡丙醚悬浮剂(SCPS)在稻田环境中对[某种螺类]的杀螺效果和成本,以便为吡丙醚在防治[该螺类]方面的广泛应用提供见解。
2022年7月,从江西省南昌市选取一块稻田作为研究区域,在研究区域内划分出72个2米×1米的独立矩形地块,每个地块间隔1米,每个地块中轻轻放入20只[该螺类]。在54个地块中测试了手动喷洒不同剂量(0.50、1.00、2.00克/平方米和4.00克/平方米)的25%硫酸吡丙醚可湿性粉剂(WPPS)对[该螺类]的活性,手动喷洒0.10克/平方米的50%氯硝柳胺乙醇胺盐可湿性粉剂(WPNES)作为化学对照,而手动喷洒相同体积的清水作为空白对照,每组9个地块。在其余18个地块中测试了SCPS对[该螺类]的活性。基于WPPS的杀螺试验,评估手动喷洒不同剂量(0.20、0.30、0.40克/平方米和0.50克/平方米)的SCPS对[该螺类]的杀螺效果,手动喷洒0.10克/平方米的WPNES作为化学对照,而手动喷洒相同体积的清水作为空白对照,每组三个地块。2023年7月,从江西省鹰潭市余江区选取14块平均活[该螺类]密度>5只/平方米的稻田进行杀螺试验。基于吡丙醚在地块中对[该螺类]的杀螺效果,测试了手动喷洒不同剂量(0.25、0.50克/平方米和1.00克/平方米)的WPPS以及不同剂量(0.25、0.50、1.00克/平方米和2.00克/平方米)的WPPS与土壤混合施用对[该螺类]的杀螺效果,手动喷洒0.10克/平方米的WPNES作为化学对照组,而手动喷洒相同体积的清水作为空白对照,每组一个稻田。基于吡丙醚在地块中对[该螺类]的效果,测试了无人机以2千克/667平方米和4千克/667平方米的水量混合喷洒不同剂量(0.25克/平方米和0.50克/平方米)的SCPS对[该螺类]的活性,无人机喷洒相同体积的清水作为空白对照。在地块和稻田进行化学处理后3天和7天捕获所有的[该螺类]并鉴定其存活情况,估算[该螺类]的死亡率和校正死亡率。此外,在稻田杀螺试验中估算化学处理面积、杀螺剂使用量和化学处理的劳动力成本,并计算无人机和人工处理667平方米面积的化学处理成本。
在地块中,喷洒0.50、1.00、2.00克/平方米和4.00克/平方米剂量的WPPS后3天和7天,[该螺类]的死亡率均为100%,不同剂量的SCPS处理后3天[该螺类]的死亡率为66.67%至100.00%(χ = 277.897,P < 0.05),处理后7天为76.67%至100.00%(χ = 274.206,P < 0.05)。在稻田中,不同剂量的WPPS处理后3天[该螺类]的死亡率为98.19%至100.00%。WPPS处理组与对照组之间[该螺类]的死亡率存在显著差异(χ = 270.778,P < 0.05),WPPS处理组与化学对照组之间无显著差异(所有P值>0.05), 而WPPS处理组与空白对照组之间[该螺类]的死亡率存在显著差异(所有P值<0.05)。无人机喷洒不同剂量的SCPS后3天[该螺类]的死亡率为89.83%至95.31%,SCPS处理组与空白对照组之间[该螺类]的死亡率存在显著差异(χ = 1132.892,P < 0.05)。SCPS处理组或水混合组之间[该螺类]的死亡率无显著差异(所有P值>0.05),而SCPS处理组与空白对照组之间[该螺类]的死亡率存在显著差异(所有P值<0.05)。无人机喷洒不同剂量的SCPS后7天[该螺类]的死亡率为94.62%至100.00%,SCPS处理组与空白对照组之间[该螺类]的死亡率存在显著差异(χ = 1266.932,P < 0.05),无人机以0.50克/平方米SCPS与2千克/667平方米水混合喷洒后的死亡率最高(P < 0.05)。无人机和人工防治[该螺类]的成本分别为35.85元/667平方米和43.33元/667平方米;然而,无人机防治[该螺类]的效率比人工高6.67倍。
无人机喷洒SCPS对稻田中的[该螺类]有很高的活性。无人机喷洒SCPS在稻田、海滩和河道防治[该螺类]高效且成本低。