Mancin Paolo, Vall-Roqué Helena, Grey Wesley, Griffiths Scott, Bonell Sarah
Department of General Psychology, University of Padua, Via Venezia, 8, 35131, Padua, Italy.
Department of Clinical Psychology and Psychobiology, Faculty of Psychology, University of Barcelona, Barcelona, Spain.
J Eat Disord. 2024 Dec 4;12(1):199. doi: 10.1186/s40337-024-01163-0.
To date, over 1.3 billion videos with the hashtag #bodyneutrality have been viewed on TikTok. Despite this, little existing literature has unpacked how body neutrality is conceptualised on TikTok. We examined how TikTok creators construct meaning and generate discourse surrounding #bodyneutrality.
Extending on previous works in the body neutrality space, we conducted a hybrid content/thematic analysis of TikTok videos in three different languages (English, Spanish, and Italian). Initially, 300 videos displaying "#bodyneutrality" were identified on TikTok. The first 178 TikTok videos were analysed, following the principles of data saturation and feasibility.
We developed three themes: (1) The normalisation of diverse bodies, (2) The rejection of appearance as fundamentally important, and (3) Body neutrality is (better than) body positivity.
In line with conceptualisations of body neutrality in existing literature, some content emphasised the importance of devaluing physical appearance. Building on existing definitions, most creators also framed body neutrality as speaking to the fundamental humanness of owning a body and attempted to normalise various body shapes/sizes. Conversely, some content employed #bodyneutrality to promote or examine body positivity principles or to condemn appearance-based stigmatisation. Our study is one of the first to examine how body neutrality is understood and employed by people in the real world.
截至目前,TikTok上带有#身体中立标签的视频浏览量已超过13亿次。尽管如此,现有文献中很少有对身体中立在TikTok上的概念化方式进行剖析的内容。我们研究了TikTok创作者如何构建意义以及围绕#身体中立产生话语。
在身体中立领域先前研究的基础上,我们对三种不同语言(英语、西班牙语和意大利语)的TikTok视频进行了混合内容/主题分析。最初,在TikTok上识别出300个展示“#身体中立”的视频。按照数据饱和和可行性原则,对前178个TikTok视频进行了分析。
我们提炼出三个主题:(1)不同身体的常态化;(2)拒绝将外表视为至关重要的因素;(3)身体中立优于身体积极。
与现有文献中身体中立的概念化一致,一些内容强调了贬低外表的重要性。在现有定义的基础上,大多数创作者还将身体中立阐释为关乎拥有身体的基本人性,并试图使各种体型/身材常态化。相反,一些内容利用#身体中立来推广或审视身体积极原则,或谴责基于外表的污名化。我们的研究是首批探究现实世界中人们如何理解和运用身体中立的研究之一。