Shnaydman Vladimir
ORBee Consulting, 57 East Bluff Rd., Ashland, MA, 01721, USA.
Ther Innov Regul Sci. 2025 Jan;59(1):173-183. doi: 10.1007/s43441-024-00722-6. Epub 2024 Dec 5.
In the high-stakes world of clinical trials, where a company's multimillion-dollar drug development investment is at risk, the increasing complexity of these trials only compounds the challenges. Therefore, the development of a robust risk mitigation strategy, as a crucial component of comprehensive risk planning, is not just important but essential for effective drug development, particularly in the RBQM (Risk-Based Quality Management) ecosystem and its component-RBM (Risk-Based Monitoring). This emphasis on the urgency and significance of risk mitigation strategy can help the audience understand the gravity of the topic. The paper introduces a novel modeling framework for deriving an efficient risk mitigation strategy at the planning stage of a clinical trial and establishing operational rules (thresholds) under the assumption that contingency resources are limited. The problem is solved in two steps: (1) Deriving a contingency budget and its efficient allocation across risks to be mitigated and (2) Deriving operational rules to be aligned with risk assessment and contingency resources. This approach is based on combining optimization and simulation models. The optimization model aims to derive an efficient contingency budget and allocate limited mitigation resources across mitigated risks. The simulation model aims to efficiently position each risk's QTL/KRI (Quality Tolerance Limits/Key Risk Indicators at a clinical trial level) and Secondary Limit thresholds. A case study illustrates the proposed technique's practical application and effectiveness. This example demonstrates the framework's potential and instills confidence in its successful implementation, reassuring the audience of its practicality and usefulness. The paper is structured as follows. (1) Introduction; (2) Methodology; (3) Models-Risk Optimizer and Risk Simulator; (4) Case study; (5) Discussion and (6) Conclusion.
在临床试验这个高风险的领域中,公司数百万美元的药物研发投资面临风险,而这些试验日益增加的复杂性只会使挑战更加复杂。因此,制定强有力的风险缓解策略作为全面风险规划的关键组成部分,对于有效的药物研发而言不仅重要而且必不可少,尤其是在基于风险的质量管理(RBQM)生态系统及其组成部分——基于风险的监测(RBM)中。对风险缓解策略的紧迫性和重要性的这种强调有助于读者理解该主题的重要性。本文介绍了一种新颖的建模框架,用于在临床试验的规划阶段得出有效的风险缓解策略,并在应急资源有限的假设下建立操作规则(阈值)。该问题分两步解决:(1)得出应急预算及其在要缓解的风险之间的有效分配;(2)得出与风险评估和应急资源相一致的操作规则。这种方法基于优化模型和模拟模型的结合。优化模型旨在得出有效的应急预算,并在已缓解的风险之间分配有限的缓解资源。模拟模型旨在有效地确定每个风险的质量容忍限度/关键风险指标(在临床试验层面)以及次要限度阈值。一个案例研究说明了所提出技术的实际应用和有效性。这个例子展示了该框架的潜力,并使其成功实施令人信服,让读者放心其实用性和有用性。本文结构如下:(1)引言;(2)方法;(3)模型——风险优化器和风险模拟器;(4)案例研究;(5)讨论;(6)结论。