Lakhani Arusa, Ali Tazeen Saeed, Kramer-Roy Debbie, Ashraf Dilshad
School of Nursing and Midwifery, Aga Khan University, Karachi, Pakistan.
European MSc in Occupational Therapy at the Amsterdam University of Applied Sciences, the Netherlands.
Heliyon. 2024 Oct 10;10(20):e39221. doi: 10.1016/j.heliyon.2024.e39221. eCollection 2024 Oct 30.
Intellectual disability (ID) is a developmental disorder that causes considerably below-average intellectual performance and adaptive behaviour. In the context of the present study, families raising a child with ID are reported to experience multiple challenges that appear not to be well documented in Pakistan.
Pakistan, which was conducted in Karachi, Pakistan, followed participatory action research, in which the researcher and participants examined their existing experiences of informal social support and then created, implemented, and evaluated actions to strengthen this informal social support. A total of five families ( = 25) participated in the study. These participating families comprise parents, siblings, and significant others, i.e., aunts, uncles, and grandparents, living with the child with ID. Families with children with ID were selected through a school for children with ID who are under 12 years old. This qualitative action research was conducted in two distinct parts, i.e., a) exploratory part and b) action part. This paper presents the findings of the first exploratory part of the study.
The exploratory phase aimed to explore and examine the experiences and challenges families may experience with informal social support while caring for a child with an intellectual disability in Karachi, Pakistan.
Parents often sacrifice their personal needs and aspirations for their children, leading to decreased tolerance and anxiety. Lack of communication, support, and assistance from family members is another significant issue. Stigmatisation and discrimination from school, relatives, and friends can cause depression and distress. The study emphasises the need for a unified and coordinated approach to support and care. Religious beliefs, siblings, and close friends provide comfort and well-being. When parents manage to connect with similar families, they have the opportunity to express a collective commitment to caregiving.
To strengthen the situation, families propose enhancing intimacy and competency within homes and taking action at the governmental level. Governments must provide appropriate services, such as nurses supporting families, support groups, and religious traditions, to promote acceptance and holistic development for intellectually disabled children.
智力残疾(ID)是一种发育障碍,会导致智力表现和适应行为显著低于平均水平。在本研究的背景下,据报道,在巴基斯坦,抚养智力残疾儿童的家庭面临多种挑战,而这些挑战似乎并未得到充分记录。
该研究在巴基斯坦卡拉奇进行,采用参与式行动研究方法,研究人员与参与者审视了他们现有的非正式社会支持经历,然后制定、实施并评估加强这种非正式社会支持的行动。共有五个家庭(n = 25)参与了研究。这些参与家庭包括与智力残疾儿童共同生活的父母、兄弟姐妹以及重要他人,即姑姑、叔叔和祖父母。通过一所面向12岁以下智力残疾儿童的学校挑选出有智力残疾儿童的家庭。这项定性行动研究分为两个不同部分,即a)探索部分和b)行动部分。本文呈现了该研究第一个探索部分的结果。
探索阶段旨在探究和审视在巴基斯坦卡拉奇,家庭在照顾智力残疾儿童时,在非正式社会支持方面可能经历的体验和挑战。
父母常常为了孩子牺牲个人需求和愿望,导致容忍度降低和焦虑情绪增加。家庭成员缺乏沟通、支持和帮助是另一个重要问题。来自学校、亲戚和朋友的污名化和歧视会导致抑郁和痛苦。该研究强调需要一种统一且协调的支持与照顾方法。宗教信仰、兄弟姐妹和亲密朋友能带来慰藉和幸福感。当父母设法与类似家庭建立联系时,他们有机会表达集体照顾的承诺。
为改善这种状况,家庭提议加强家庭内部的亲密关系和能力,并在政府层面采取行动。政府必须提供适当服务,如为家庭提供支持的护士、支持小组和宗教传统,以促进对智力残疾儿童的接纳和全面发展。