El Tantawi Maha, Bhayat Ahmed, Foláyan Moréniké Oluwátóyìn
Department of Pediatric Dentistry and Dental Public Health, Faculty of Dentistry, Alexandria University, Alexandria, Egypt.
Afrone Network, Faculty of Dentistry, Alexandria University, Alexandria, Egypt.
Front Oral Health. 2024 Nov 21;5:1498827. doi: 10.3389/froh.2024.1498827. eCollection 2024.
The successful implementation of the 2030 sustainable development Agenda in Africa requires active participation from all sectors, including the dental research sector. The aim of this study was to review dental research published by authors affiliated with institutions in African countries from 2016 to 2023, to map papers related to the sustainable development goals (SDGs), and to identify areas of emphasis and gaps in SDGs-related papers on oral health in Africa.
We conducted a bibliometric analysis of dental literature in Africa (2016-2023) using Scival for performance analysis and VOSviewer for science mapping. The papers addressing and not addressing the SDGs were compared regarding impact, authorship metrics and key phrases. We identified the topic clusters with the greatest number of papers. The key phrase co-occurrence networks and the authors and countries collaboration networks were mapped.
There were 4,173 papers and 622 (14.9%) addressed the SDGs, especially SDG3. SDGs papers had greater impact and were more likely to be published in open access journals than non-SDGs papers. Egypt, Nigeria and South Africa had the greatest number of papers and citations. Four of the top ten authors were females. Most of the top ten journals were open access and only three were in quartile 1 (Q1) journals. Springer and Elsevier were the top publishers. The top research clusters addressed rehabilitative care including implants, endodontics, ceramics and zirconia. SDGs papers, however, addressed oral hygiene in caries prevention and to control systemic diseases. Collaboration networks were affected by geographic location and languages. Dental research in Africa is concentrated in three countries and mainly addresses rehabilitative care. SDGs papers had an impact above the global average and addressed prevention and non-communicable diseases.
There is minimal yet increasing contribution of African countries to the evidence on oral health and the SDGs. The focus is on a limited number of SDGs, and publications are from very few countries in Africa. There is a need to focus oral health-related SDGs research on addressing local problems.
2030年可持续发展议程在非洲的成功实施需要包括牙科研究部门在内的所有部门积极参与。本研究的目的是回顾2016年至2023年非洲国家机构附属作者发表的牙科研究,绘制与可持续发展目标(SDGs)相关的论文,并确定非洲与SDGs相关的口腔健康论文的重点领域和差距。
我们使用Scival进行绩效分析,VOSviewer进行科学绘图,对非洲(2016 - 2023年)的牙科文献进行文献计量分析。比较了涉及和未涉及SDGs的论文在影响力、作者指标和关键词方面的情况。我们确定了论文数量最多的主题集群。绘制了关键词共现网络以及作者和国家合作网络。
共有4173篇论文,其中622篇(14.9%)涉及SDGs,特别是SDG3。与非SDGs论文相比,SDGs论文具有更大的影响力,并且更有可能发表在开放获取期刊上。埃及、尼日利亚和南非的论文数量和引用次数最多。前十位作者中有四位是女性。前十种期刊中的大多数是开放获取期刊,只有三种是一区(Q1)期刊。施普林格和爱思唯尔是顶级出版商。顶级研究集群涉及修复治疗,包括种植体、牙髓病学、陶瓷和氧化锆。然而,SDGs论文涉及龋齿预防中的口腔卫生以及控制全身性疾病。合作网络受到地理位置和语言的影响。非洲的牙科研究集中在三个国家,主要涉及修复治疗。SDGs论文的影响力高于全球平均水平,涉及预防和非传染性疾病。
非洲国家对口腔健康和SDGs证据的贡献微乎其微,但在不断增加。重点集中在少数几个SDGs上,而且出版物来自非洲极少数国家。有必要将与口腔健康相关的SDGs研究重点放在解决当地问题上。