van Breen Jolien, Rijcken Emil, Kantorowicz Jaroslaw, Liem Marieke
Leiden University, Den Haag, Netherlands.
Eindhoven University of Technology, Netherlands.
J Interpers Violence. 2025 Nov;40(21-22):5072-5094. doi: 10.1177/08862605241301793. Epub 2024 Dec 6.
This paper examines the meaning of violence in contemporary Western societies. Scholars have argued that in contemporary Western societies, the concept is expanding toward a broader understanding of violence, beyond its "traditional" usage in the context of crime and war. The current paper aims to generate empirical evidence that speaks to this question. We take the Netherlands as a case study and apply machine learning techniques to discourse on violence in 80,000 articles published in national newspapers between 2012 and 2021. Results show that the public discourse on violence in the Netherlands has a component that can be described as the familiar or "traditional" usage of the term violence-referring to violent political conflicts, or interpersonal violence such as child abuse. Beyond this, the term violence is associated with discourse on societal challenges. It appears in discourse on social media, political polarization, and social injustice faced by ethnic minorities, women, and the LGBT+ community. The later stages of the analysis demonstrated that the terms associated with social injustice in particular (e.g., "racist") become more closely associated with the concept of violence over time. In short, our findings support the notion that the collective understanding of violence in the Netherlands is developing toward a broader understanding of violence, beyond the context of crime and war. Specifically, in recent years the term violence is increasingly used in association with issues of social injustice.
本文探讨了当代西方社会中暴力的含义。学者们认为,在当代西方社会,这一概念正朝着对暴力更广泛的理解扩展,超越了其在犯罪和战争背景下的“传统”用法。本文旨在提供与这一问题相关的实证证据。我们以荷兰为例进行研究,并运用机器学习技术分析了2012年至2021年期间荷兰全国性报纸上发表的8万篇关于暴力的文章。结果表明,荷兰公众对暴力的讨论中有一部分可以被描述为对暴力一词常见的或“传统”的用法——指暴力政治冲突或人际暴力,如虐待儿童。除此之外,暴力一词还与关于社会挑战的讨论相关。它出现在关于社交媒体、政治两极分化以及少数族裔、女性和 LGBT+ 群体所面临的社会不公的讨论中。分析的后期阶段表明,特别是与社会不公相关的词汇(如“种族主义者”)随着时间的推移与暴力概念的联系越来越紧密。简而言之,我们的研究结果支持了这样一种观点,即荷兰对暴力的集体认知正在朝着对暴力更广泛的理解发展,超越了犯罪和战争的范畴。具体而言,近年来,暴力一词越来越多地与社会不公问题联系在一起。