Gomes Brenda Lorrana de Almeida, Sousa Renata Sant'ana Braga de, Mota Renan Felipe Neves, Nunes Cynthia Assis de Barros, Vieira Nayara Figueiredo, Oliveira Nunila Ferreira de, Gonzalez Roxana Isabel Cardozo, Pagotto Valéria
Universidade Federal de Goiás, Faculdade de Enfermagem, Goiânia, GO, Brazil.
Universidade Federal de Catalão, Catalão, GO, Brazil.
Rev Esc Enferm USP. 2024 Dec 6;58:e20240149. doi: 10.1590/1980-220X-REEUSP-2024-0149en. eCollection 2024.
To identify the scientific evidence on the performance of PHC, based on the presence and extent of its attributes, in the view of nurses and physicians.
Scoping review according to the recommendations of the Joanna Brigss Institute, carried out between January 2023 on eight databases, and updated in December 2023. The keywords "primary health care assessment" and "quality of primary health care" were used. Articles in any language were included, which used the PCATool-Brazil instrument, professional version, with a population of nurses and physicians.
Nineteen studies were included, published between 2012 and 2022, in nine Brazilian states. The overall average of PHC performance ranged from 6.5 to 8.2 and only two of the total indicated low performance of PHC services. Regarding the attributes, accessibility showed the worst performance and family orientation the best in all the studies. Specialization and statutory employment were predominantly frequent as associated factors.
The results show that access to health services still needs to be strengthened and/or expanded and that, on the other hand, factors such as training and worker attachment strengthen PHC performance.
从护士和医生的角度,根据初级卫生保健(PHC)属性的存在情况和程度,确定关于其绩效的科学证据。
根据乔安娜·布里格斯研究所的建议进行范围综述,于2023年1月至8个数据库开展,并于2023年12月更新。使用了关键词“初级卫生保健评估”和“初级卫生保健质量”。纳入了任何语言的文章,这些文章使用了巴西初级卫生保健评估工具(PCATool)专业版,研究对象为护士和医生群体。
纳入了19项研究,这些研究于2012年至2022年期间在巴西9个州发表。初级卫生保健绩效的总体平均水平在6.5至8.2之间,在所有研究中,只有两项表明初级卫生保健服务绩效较低。关于各项属性,在所有研究中,可及性表现最差,家庭导向性表现最佳。专业化和法定就业作为相关因素最为常见。
结果表明,卫生服务的可及性仍需加强和/或扩大,另一方面,培训和工作人员归属感等因素可提高初级卫生保健绩效。