Tucker-Shabazz AunRika, Kim Veda Hyunjin
Department of Sociology, University of Michigan Ann Arbor, Ann Arbor, Michigan, USA.
Department of Sociology and Anthropology, Ohio Wesleyan University, Delaware, Ohio, USA.
Br J Sociol. 2025 Mar;76(2):376-389. doi: 10.1111/1468-4446.13179. Epub 2024 Dec 11.
Treasuring the legacy of Ida B Wells-Barnett as a Black feminist is a vital liberatory commitment, as previous scholarship has commendably demonstrated. Equally important, however, is the need to present Wells-Barnett as an anticolonial theorist whose scholarly texts-Southern Horrors, A Red Record, and Crusade for Justice-should be incorporated into social theory curricula. This article examines Wells-Barnett's acute apprehension of the foundational structures of the US empire-state in her scholarly writings on lynching. As she analysed, the white mob violence epitomised the co-re-formation of race and gender, rule of difference, and subversion of offender-judge relationship. The agency of non-state actors (e.g., lynch mobs) and government agents (e.g., judge and politicians) co-constituted the reformation-not total transformation-of these foundational structures. Lynching, therefore, was the lynchpin of the US empire-state in the post-Reconstruction period: it sustained the white supremacist order by imposing a mass death penalty on Black people, while simultaneously serving as a disgrace to US civilization. To conclude, we highlight how Wells-Barnett's theory offers broader relevance to anticolonial/postcolonial sociology, particularly through her subaltern standpoint, attention to the role of non-state actors, and her commitment to intersectional analysis.
正如先前的学术研究所出色证明的那样,珍视伊达·B·韦尔斯-巴尼特作为黑人女权主义者的遗产是一项至关重要的解放承诺。然而,同样重要的是,有必要将韦尔斯-巴尼特视为一位反殖民理论家,她的学术著作《南方恐怖》《红色记录》和《正义的 crusade》应纳入社会理论课程。本文考察了韦尔斯-巴尼特在其关于私刑的学术著作中对美国帝国国家基础结构的敏锐洞察。正如她所分析的,白人暴民暴力体现了种族和性别的共同重塑、差异规则以及对罪犯-法官关系的颠覆。非国家行为者(如私刑暴民)和政府行为者(如法官和政治家)的行为共同构成了这些基础结构的重塑——而非彻底转变。因此,私刑是重建后美国帝国国家的关键:它通过对黑人施加大规模死刑来维持白人至上主义秩序,同时又成为美国文明的耻辱。最后,我们强调韦尔斯-巴尼特的理论如何与反殖民/后殖民社会学具有更广泛的相关性,特别是通过她的底层视角、对非国家行为者角色的关注以及她对交叉性分析的承诺。