Watson Stuart Kyle, Zali Mara, Falk Nikola, Widmer Paul, Manser Marta B
Department of Evolutionary Biology and Environmental Studies, University of Zürich, Winterthurerstrasse 190, Zurich 8057, Switzerland.
Center for the Interdisciplinary Study of Language Evolution, University of Zürich, Zürich, Switzerland.
R Soc Open Sci. 2024 Dec 11;11(12):241351. doi: 10.1098/rsos.241351. eCollection 2024 Dec.
Diverse information encoding systems, including human language, the vocal and gestural systems of non-human animals and the structure of DNA and proteins, have been found to conform to 'Menzerath's Law'-a negative relationship between the number of units composing a sequence, and the size of those units. Here, we test for the presence of Menzerath's Law in the vocal bouts produced in a submissive context by meerkats (). Using a suite of Bayesian mixed effects models, we examined 1676 vocal bouts produced by 89 wild meerkats, ranging from 1 to 590 calls in length, to determine whether the number of calls composing each bout had a negative relationship with the duration of those calls or their inter-call intervals. In contradiction to Menzerath's Law, we found that the duration of vocalizations had a positive relationship with the number of calls in a bout. However, the duration of intervals between calls did have a negative relationship with bout size. Moreover, both calls and intervals had longer durations the closer they were positioned to the end of the bout. These findings highlight the multi-faceted ways in which efficiency trade-offs can occur in the vocal repertoires of non-human animals, shaping variability in the production of signal forms.
包括人类语言、非人类动物的发声和手势系统以及DNA和蛋白质结构在内的各种信息编码系统,已被发现符合“门泽拉斯定律”——即组成序列的单元数量与这些单元的大小之间存在负相关关系。在此,我们测试了狐獴在顺从情境下发出的发声回合中是否存在门泽拉斯定律。我们使用一套贝叶斯混合效应模型,研究了89只野生狐獴产生的1676个发声回合,这些回合的长度从1到590次叫声不等,以确定组成每个回合的叫声数量是否与这些叫声的持续时间或叫声之间的间隔时间存在负相关关系。与门泽拉斯定律相反,我们发现发声的持续时间与回合中的叫声数量呈正相关。然而,叫声之间的间隔时间确实与回合大小呈负相关。此外,叫声和间隔距离回合末尾越近,持续时间就越长。这些发现凸显了非人类动物发声库中可能出现效率权衡的多方面方式,塑造了信号形式产生的变异性。