Department of Comparative Language Science, University of Zurich, Zurich, Switzerland.
Center for the Interdisciplinary Study of Language Evolution, University of Zurich, Zurich, Switzerland.
Biol Lett. 2020 Oct;16(10):20200380. doi: 10.1098/rsbl.2020.0380. Epub 2020 Oct 14.
Menzerath's law, traditionally framed as a negative relationship between the size of a structure and its constituent parts (e.g. sentences with more clauses have shorter clauses), is widespread across information-coding systems ranging from human language and the vocal and gestural sequences of primates and birds, to the building blocks of DNA, genes and proteins. Here, we analysed an extensive dataset of 'close-call' sequences produced by wild mountain gorillas (, no. individuals = 10, no. sequences = 2189) to determine whether, in accordance with Menzerath's law, a negative relationship existed between the number of vocal units in a sequence and the duration of its constituent units. We initially found positive evidence for this but, on closer inspection, the negative relationship was driven entirely by the difference between single- and multi-unit (two to six unit) sequences. Once single-unit sequences were excluded from the analysis, we identified a relationship in the opposite direction, with longer sequences generally composed of longer units. The close-call sequences of mountain gorillas therefore represent an intriguing example of a non-human vocal system that only partially conforms to the predictions of Menzerath's law.
门泽拉特定律,传统上被表述为结构的大小与其组成部分之间的负相关关系(例如,包含更多子句的句子具有更短的子句),广泛存在于信息编码系统中,从人类语言和灵长类动物和鸟类的声音和手势序列,到 DNA、基因和蛋白质的构建块。在这里,我们分析了野生山地大猩猩产生的大量“险象环生”序列数据集(,个体数量=10,序列数量=2189),以确定序列中声音单元的数量与组成单元的持续时间之间是否存在负相关关系,这符合门泽拉特定律。我们最初发现了这方面的积极证据,但仔细观察后发现,这种负相关关系完全是由单单元和多单元(两到六个单元)序列之间的差异驱动的。一旦从分析中排除了单单元序列,我们就确定了一个相反方向的关系,一般来说,较长的序列由较长的单元组成。因此,山地大猩猩的险象环生序列代表了一个有趣的非人类声音系统的例子,该系统仅部分符合门泽拉特定律的预测。