Jones Catherine, Cui Yi, Jeminiwa Ruth, Bajracharya Elina, Chang Katie, Ma Tony
Werbie LLC, 4803 Dover Court, Bethesda, MD, 20816, United States, 1 301 283 8703.
Benten Technologies, Manassas, VA, United States.
JMIR Diabetes. 2024 Dec 12;9:e58327. doi: 10.2196/58327.
Gestational diabetes mellitus (GDM) is an increasingly common high-risk pregnancy condition requiring intensive daily self-management, placing the burden of care directly on the patient. Understanding personal and cultural differences among patients is critical for delivering optimal support for GDM self-management, particularly in high-risk populations. Although mobile apps for GDM self-management are being used, limited research has been done on the personalized and culturally tailored features of these apps and their impact on patient self-management.
This scoping review aims to explore the extent to which published studies report the integration and effectiveness of personalized and culturally tailored features in GDM mobile apps for patient self-management support.
We examined English-language peer-reviewed articles published between October 2016 and May 2023 from PubMed, CINAHL, PsycINFO, ClinicalTrials.gov, Proquest Research Library, and Google Scholar using search terms related to digital tools, diabetes, pregnancy, and cultural tailoring. We reviewed eligible articles and extracted data using the Arskey and O'Malley methodological framework.
Our search yielded a total of 1772 articles after the removal of duplicates and 158 articles for full-text review. A total of 21 articles that researched 15 GDM mobile apps were selected for data extraction. Our results demonstrated the stark contrast between the number of GDM mobile apps with personalized features for the individual user (all 15 mobile apps) and those culturally tailored for a specific population (only 3 of the 15 mobile apps). Our findings showed that GDM mobile apps with personalized and culturally tailored features were perceived to be useful to patients and had the potential to improve patients' adherence to glycemic control and nutrition plans.
There is a strong need for increased research and development to foster the implementation of personalized and culturally tailored features in GDM mobile apps for self-management that cater to patients from diverse backgrounds and ethnicities. Personalized and culturally tailored features have the potential to serve the unique needs of patients more efficiently and effectively than generic features alone; however, the impacts of such features still need to be adequately studied. Recommendations for future research include examining the cultural needs of different ethnicities within the increasingly diverse US population in the context of GDM self-management, conducting participatory-based research with these groups, and designing human-centered mobile health solutions for both patients and providers.
妊娠期糖尿病(GDM)是一种日益常见的高危妊娠状况,需要患者每天进行强化自我管理,这直接给患者带来了护理负担。了解患者之间的个人和文化差异对于为GDM自我管理提供最佳支持至关重要,尤其是在高危人群中。尽管用于GDM自我管理的移动应用程序正在被使用,但关于这些应用程序的个性化和文化定制功能及其对患者自我管理的影响的研究却很有限。
本范围综述旨在探讨已发表的研究在多大程度上报告了GDM移动应用程序中用于患者自我管理支持的个性化和文化定制功能的整合情况及有效性。
我们使用与数字工具、糖尿病、妊娠和文化定制相关的搜索词,检索了2016年10月至2023年5月期间在PubMed、CINAHL、PsycINFO、ClinicalTrials.gov、Proquest Research Library和谷歌学术上发表的英文同行评审文章。我们对符合条件的文章进行了综述,并使用Arskey和O'Malley的方法框架提取了数据。
在去除重复文章后,我们共检索到1772篇文章,其中158篇文章进行全文评审。总共选择了21篇研究15款GDM移动应用程序的文章进行数据提取。我们的结果显示,具有针对个体用户的个性化功能的GDM移动应用程序数量(所有15款移动应用程序)与针对特定人群进行文化定制的应用程序数量(15款移动应用程序中只有3款)形成了鲜明对比。我们的研究结果表明,具有个性化和文化定制功能的GDM移动应用程序被认为对患者有用,并且有可能提高患者对血糖控制和营养计划的依从性。
迫切需要加强研发,以促进在GDM移动应用程序中实施针对自我管理的个性化和文化定制功能,以满足来自不同背景和种族患者的需求。个性化和文化定制功能有可能比单独的通用功能更高效、有效地满足患者的独特需求;然而,此类功能的影响仍需充分研究。对未来研究的建议包括在GDM自我管理的背景下研究日益多样化的美国人群中不同种族的文化需求、与这些群体开展基于参与式的研究,以及为患者和提供者设计以人为本的移动健康解决方案。