Fernandez Isabel Diana, Yang Yu-Ching, Chang Wonkyung, Kautz Amber, Farchaus Stein Karen
Department of Public Health Sciences, Division of Epidemiology, University of Rochester School of Medicine and Dentistry, Rochester, NY, United States.
School of Nursing, University of Rochester Medical Center, Rochester, NY, United States.
JMIR Form Res. 2024 Dec 13;8:e54664. doi: 10.2196/54664.
Rural-urban disparities in access to health services and the burden of diet-related noncommunicable diseases are exacerbated among Mexican immigrant farmworkers due to work demands, social and geographical isolation, literacy issues, and limited access to culturally and language-competent health services. Although mobile health (mHealth) tools have the potential to overcome structural barriers to health services access, efficacious mHealth interventions to promote healthy eating have not considered issues of low literacy and health literacy, and food preferences and norms in the Mexican immigrant farmworker population. To address this critical gap, we conducted a series of preliminary studies among Mexican immigrant farmworkers with the long-term goal of developing a culture- and literacy-specific smartphone app integrating dietary assessment through food photography, diet analyses, and a non-text-based dietary intervention.
This study aimed to report adherence and reactivity to a 14-day food photography dietary assessment protocol, in which Mexican immigrant farmworker women were instructed to take photos of all foods and beverages consumed.
We developed a secure mobile app with an intuitive graphical user interface to collect food images. Adult Mexican immigrant farmworker women were recruited and oriented to the photography protocol. Adherence and reactivity were examined by calculating the mean number of food photos per day over time, differences between the first and second week, and differences between weekdays and weekends. The type of foods and meals photographed were compared with reported intake in three 24-hour dietary recalls.
In total, 16 Mexican farmworker women took a total of 1475 photos in 14 days, with a mean of 6.6 (SD 2.3) photos per day per participant. On average, participants took 1 fewer photo per day in week 2 compared with week 1 (mean 7.1, SD 2.5 in week 1 vs mean 6.1, SD 2.6 in week 2; P=.03), and there was a decrease of 0.6 photos on weekdays versus weekends (mean 6.4, SD 2.5 on weekdays vs mean 7, SD 2.7 on weekends; P=.50). Of individual food items, 71% (352/495) of foods in the photos matched foods in the recalls. Of all missing food items (n=138) and meals (n=36) in the photos, beverages (74/138, 54%), tortillas (15/138, 11%), snacks 16/36, 44%), and dinners (10/36, 28%) were the most frequently missed. Most of the meals not photographed (27/36, 75%) were in the second week of the protocol.
Dietary assessment through food photography is feasible among Mexican immigrant farmworker women. For future protocols, substantive adjustments will be introduced to reduce the frequency of missing foods and meals. Our preliminary studies are a step in the right direction to extend the benefits of mHealth technologies to a hard-to-reach group and contribute to the prevention and control of diet-related noncommunicable diseases.
由于工作需求、社会和地理隔离、识字问题以及获得具有文化和语言能力的医疗服务的机会有限,墨西哥移民农场工人在获得医疗服务方面的城乡差距以及与饮食相关的非传染性疾病负担加剧。尽管移动健康(mHealth)工具有可能克服获得医疗服务的结构性障碍,但促进健康饮食的有效mHealth干预措施尚未考虑墨西哥移民农场工人人口中的低识字率和健康素养问题,以及食物偏好和规范。为了弥补这一关键差距,我们对墨西哥移民农场工人进行了一系列初步研究,其长期目标是开发一款针对特定文化和识字水平的智能手机应用程序,该应用程序通过食物摄影、饮食分析和非文本形式的饮食干预来整合饮食评估。
本研究旨在报告对一项为期14天的食物摄影饮食评估方案的依从性和反应性,该方案中指导墨西哥移民农场工人女性拍摄所有食用的食物和饮料的照片。
我们开发了一款具有直观图形用户界面的安全移动应用程序来收集食物图像。招募成年墨西哥移民农场工人女性并使其熟悉摄影方案。通过计算随时间推移每天食物照片的平均数、第一周和第二周之间的差异以及工作日和周末之间的差异来检查依从性和反应性。将拍摄的食物和餐食类型与三次24小时饮食回顾中报告的摄入量进行比较。
共有16名墨西哥农场工人女性在14天内共拍摄了1475张照片,每位参与者每天平均拍摄6.6张(标准差2.3)照片。平均而言,与第一周相比,参与者在第二周每天少拍1张照片(第一周平均7.1张,标准差2.5;第二周平均6.1张,标准差2.6;P = 0.03),工作日比周末少拍0.6张照片(工作日平均6.4张,标准差2.5;周末平均7张,标准差2.7;P = 0.50)。在单个食物项目中,照片中的食物有71%(352/495)与饮食回顾中的食物相符。照片中所有缺失的食物项目(n = 138)和餐食(n = 36)中,饮料(74/138,54%)、玉米饼(15/138,11%)、零食(16/36,44%)和晚餐(10/36,28%)是最常缺失的。大多数未拍摄的餐食(27/36,75%)出现在方案的第二周。
通过食物摄影进行饮食评估在墨西哥移民农场工人女性中是可行的。对于未来的方案,将进行实质性调整以减少食物和餐食缺失的频率。我们的初步研究是朝着正确方向迈出的一步,将移动健康技术的益处扩展到难以接触的群体,并有助于预防和控制与饮食相关的非传染性疾病。