Mariani Melissa, Schiff Mara
Human Development & Organizational Studies in Education (HDOSE), University of Florida, College of Education, Gainesville, FL, USA.
School of Criminology & Criminal Justice, FAU College of Social Work & Criminal Justice, US Global Fulbright Scholar to KU Leuven, Leuven, Belgium.
J Sch Health. 2025 Mar;95(3):280-290. doi: 10.1111/josh.13528. Epub 2024 Dec 15.
School violence is a significant public health concern. Most perpetrators exhibit psychosocial and behavioral warning signals which are often inadequately addressed. While policy and funding typically reinforce politically popular target hardening and threat assessment strategies, these are not most supported by research or requested by education faculty and administration.
The most common threats to school safety are ubiquitous events causing students to feel disconnected, alienated, isolated, and unsafe in school. Theoretical and empirical research indicates that focusing on rare but extreme school violence is less productive than preventative approaches including universal socio-emotional programs, mental health supports, and climate and culture building to produce effective strategies for safe school environments.
IMPLICATIONS FOR SCHOOL HEALTH POLICY, PRACTICE, AND EQUITY: Comprehensive school safety plans should include three essential preventative components: (1) targeted, student-centered approaches addressing social, emotional, and behavioral wellbeing; (2) equity-focused institutional culture and climate approaches aligned with appropriate disciplinary strategies; and (3) well-defined target hardening, threat assessment and reporting measures.
Increasing evidence suggests that keeping schools safe requires coordinated approaches to school safety including student-centered psycho-social behavioral initiatives, systematic attention to equitable culture and climate, and meaningful, racially sensitive target hardening coordinated among and between service professionals.
校园暴力是一个重大的公共卫生问题。大多数施暴者表现出社会心理和行为方面的警示信号,但这些信号往往未得到充分关注。虽然政策和资金通常强化政治上受欢迎的加强目标安保和威胁评估策略,但这些策略在研究中并未得到最多支持,也不是教育教职员工和管理人员所要求的。
对学校安全最常见的威胁是普遍存在的事件,这些事件导致学生在学校感到脱节、疏离、孤立和不安全。理论和实证研究表明,关注罕见但极端的校园暴力不如采取预防方法有效,这些预防方法包括普及社会情感项目、心理健康支持以及营造校园氛围和文化,以制定安全校园环境的有效策略。
对学校卫生政策、实践和公平性的启示:全面的学校安全计划应包括三个基本的预防要素:(1)以学生为中心的针对性方法,解决社会、情感和行为健康问题;(2)注重公平的机构文化和氛围营造方法,与适当的纪律策略相结合;(3)明确界定的加强目标安保、威胁评估和报告措施。
越来越多的证据表明,保障学校安全需要采取协调一致的学校安全方法,包括以学生为中心的心理社会行为举措、对公平文化和氛围的系统关注,以及服务专业人员之间有意义的、对种族敏感的加强目标安保措施。