Rouse Miranda, Mphande Isaac, Mwale Nelson, Kapira Sitalire, Sayenda Mphatso, Mvula Mc Geofrey, Openshaw Maria, Kapito Esnath, Kutsamba Martha, Maweu Daniel, Mitchell Ashley, Dandu Madhavi, Muller Anna, Blair Alden Hooper, Baltzell Kimberly
University of California, San Francisco, Institute for Global Health Sciences, Mission Hall, 550 16Th Street, Third Floor, Box 1224, San Francisco, CA, 94158, USA.
Partners In Health/Abwenzi Pa Za Umoyo, P.O. Box 56, Neno, Malawi.
BMC Glob Public Health. 2024 Nov 11;2(1):74. doi: 10.1186/s44263-024-00107-9.
There is critical need to strengthen the global nursing and midwifery workforce. This is especially true in Malawi where they are the primary providers of obstetric and neonatal care. In Neno district, Malawi, in 2017, we implemented an intensive training and longitudinal bedside mentorship intervention for nurses and midwives. From inception, there was a pre-planned project target completion after 5 years, including a staged handover to local ownership after 3 years. The objective of this study was to assess differences in reported maternal and neonatal complications following project completion and handover to local leadership.
The project was a partnership between an academic institution and local nongovernmental organization. In October 2020, the intervention was handed over and maintained by the local organization with limited support from the academic institution. Data from January 2019 to May 2023 were extracted from the Malawi District Health Information Software 2. Bivariate analyses explored differences in the pre- and post-handover periods for all government-collected, birth-related variables. The "pre-handover" period encompassed January 2019 to September 2020 and "post-handover" from October 2020 to May 2023. Multivariate linear regression explored outcomes while controlling for health facility.
Data were collected from 10 health facilities in the district and included a total of 23,259 births. Overall, there were few significant changes between periods. Exceptions were in reporting of antepartum hemorrhage (p < 0.01), maternal sepsis (p = 0.01), and manual removal of the placenta (p < 0.01), where we observed decreases in reporting. There was a significant decrease in the reporting of neonatal sepsis (p = 0.01) in the bivariate analysis, which remained only borderline significant in the multivariate model (p = 0.05). Where differences occurred, they were associated with improvements in reported identification of complications and provision of associated emergency care.
Few differences in reported maternal and neonatal complications between the periods suggest positive impact of the intervention was sustained following project handover and transition of activities to local leadership. These findings strengthen support for longitudinal mentorship as a pivotal component for skill retention after training. Transparent partnerships which include pre-determined end points and time for handover of activities to local ownership are crucial components for sustainability.
全球迫切需要加强护理和助产人员队伍。在马拉维尤其如此,因为她们是产科和新生儿护理的主要提供者。2017年,在马拉维的内诺区,我们对护士和助产士实施了强化培训和长期床边指导干预。从一开始,就预先计划在5年后完成项目目标,包括在3年后分阶段移交给当地自主管理。本研究的目的是评估项目完成并移交给当地领导后,报告的孕产妇和新生儿并发症的差异。
该项目是一个学术机构与当地非政府组织之间的合作项目。2020年10月,该干预措施由当地组织接管并维持,学术机构提供有限的支持。从2019年1月至2023年5月的数据从马拉维地区卫生信息软件2中提取。双变量分析探讨了所有政府收集的、与分娩相关变量在移交前后的差异。“移交前”时期涵盖2019年1月至2020年9月,“移交后”时期为2020年10月至2023年5月。多变量线性回归在控制卫生设施的同时探讨结果。
从该地区的10个卫生设施收集了数据,共包括23259例分娩。总体而言,各时期之间几乎没有显著变化。例外情况是产前出血(p<0.01)、孕产妇败血症(p=0.01)和人工剥离胎盘(p<0.01)的报告,我们观察到报告数量有所下降。双变量分析中新生儿败血症的报告显著减少(p=0.01),在多变量模型中仅边缘显著(p=0.05)。出现差异的地方与报告的并发症识别和相关急救提供的改善有关。
各时期报告的孕产妇和新生儿并发症差异不大,表明干预措施在项目移交和活动转交给当地领导后持续产生了积极影响。这些发现加强了对长期指导作为培训后技能保留关键组成部分的支持。包括预先确定的终点和将活动移交给当地自主管理的时间在内的透明伙伴关系是可持续性的关键组成部分。