Lins Maísa Fernandes Caixeta, Botelho Raquel Braz Assunção, Romão Bernardo, Torres Maria Luiza, Guimarães Nathalia Sernizon, Zandonadi Renata Puppin
Graduate Program in Human Nutrition, Department of Nutrition, University of Brasília, Brasília 70910-900, Brazil.
Department of Nutrition, University of Brasília, Brasília 70910-900, Brazil.
Foods. 2024 Dec 5;13(23):3933. doi: 10.3390/foods13233933.
Home-cooked meals are linked to healthier diets, but assessing cooking skills accurately remains challenging. This review aimed to evaluate and compare available validated instruments to assess adult cooking skills; the Joanna Briggs Institute's manual and PRISMA-ScR checklist were followed. A search was conducted in April 2024 in five databases using MeSH Terms and adaptations, including studies written without time or language restrictions and with validated instruments to assess adult cooking skills. Reviews, conference abstracts, books, chapters, and case reports were excluded; 1070 studies were identified, and 38 remained after removing duplicates and applying eligibility criteria. Eleven different instruments were identified. Some instruments have been successfully adapted and validated in various countries, covering a broad range of skills, such as meal organization, preparation and cooking techniques, providing a thorough assessment of cooking skills. The Cooking and Food Skill Confidence Questionnaire was considered the best available model, considering its items and domains, direct relation to cooking skills, and easy translation into other cultures. The analysis revealed significant variations in the scales used, with some instruments offering detailed assessments of specific cooking techniques and easy cultural adaptation while others focused more on confidence and attitudes.
家常饭菜与更健康的饮食相关,但准确评估烹饪技能仍然具有挑战性。本综述旨在评估和比较现有的经过验证的用于评估成人烹饪技能的工具;遵循了乔安娜·布里格斯研究所的手册和PRISMA-ScR清单。2024年4月在五个数据库中使用医学主题词及其变体进行了检索,包括不受时间或语言限制且带有用于评估成人烹饪技能的经过验证工具的研究。排除了综述、会议摘要、书籍、章节和病例报告;共识别出1070项研究,在去除重复项并应用纳入标准后,剩下38项。识别出了11种不同的工具。一些工具已在不同国家成功改编和验证,涵盖了广泛的技能,如膳食组织、准备和烹饪技巧,对烹饪技能进行了全面评估。考虑到其项目和领域、与烹饪技能的直接关系以及易于翻译成其他文化,《烹饪与食品技能信心问卷》被认为是现有的最佳模型。分析显示所使用的量表存在显著差异,一些工具对特定烹饪技巧进行了详细评估且易于进行文化改编,而另一些则更侧重于信心和态度。